More stories

  • in

    Leeds captain Liam Cooper sent off for high tackle on Man City’s Gabriel Jesus as fans fume at overturned decision

    LEEDS fans were left incensed by Andre Marriner’s decision to send off Liam Cooper during their stunning victory over Manchester City.Their skipper was dismissed for a high challenge on Gabriel Jesus, having initially been booked before VAR upgraded the punishment.
    Cooper catches Gabriel Jesus’ right kneeCredit: BT Sport
    Referee Marriner initially books the 29-year-old but is advised by VAR to have a second lookCredit: News Group Newspapers Ltd
    Cooper receives a red cardCredit: Getty
    With the West Yorkshire side winning 1-0 just before half-time, Cooper was shown a yellow card for fouling Jesus.
    The defender did get the ball but was reckless, catching the Brazilian’s right knee with his studs.
    Referee Marriner initially awarded a yellow card for the challenge but was informed by the VAR official to have a second look.
    Having watched the slowed-down footage, Marriner upgraded Cooper’s punishment to a red card.

    Leeds’ hopes of a shock win against the champions-elect appeared to have gone in the 75th minute when Ferran Torres equalised.
    But a 91st minute strike from Stuart Dallas, who scored the opener just moments before Cooper was sent off, secured all three points for the ten men.
    FREE BETS: GET OVER £2,000 IN SIGN UP OFFERS HERE
    Thats a harsh yellow as its a cracking tackle but a red WTF!— Greg Paterson (@GP) April 10, 2021

    That’s 100% a red card. He’s off the ground.— DM (@DavidMeyler) April 10, 2021

    Cooper’s dismissal had left Leeds fans fuming on social media, with many claiming he got the ball.
    One wrote on Twitter: “Complete and utter joke the state of decisions in this league!”
    Another wrote: “Absolute travesty. This isn’t football anymore.”
    But others have backed the decision, with one tweeting: “That is so obviously a red card. Ridiculously high, very late.”

    Marriner’s verdict was also supported by both Rio Ferdinand and Joleon Lescott, BT Sport’s pundits for the game.
    Ferdinand, who played for Leeds between 2000 and 2002, said: “When you come off your feet like that, it [a red card] is the letter of the law… it’s a bad tackle.”
    Former City defender Lescott added: “He got a piece of the ball, but there’s no need to tackle like that. It’s a bad tackle and the right decision.”
    ⚽ Read our Football live blog for the very latest news from around the grounds
    Leeds ace Illan Meslier saves the ball every time as he shows off his skills in training More

  • in

    Mike Dean set to make retirement U-turn and carry on refereeing in Premier League next season after fan return

    PREMIER LEAGUE stars are set to face up to referee Mike Dean for another season amid reports he will delay his retirement.The 52-year-old is approaching the end of his 21st season in the top-flight, in a career that has seen him become one of the most recognisable officials in the country.
    Mike Dean is set to stick around for another year in the Premier LeagueCredit: Ian Hodgson – Daily Mail
    According to The Athletic, Dean is preparing to continue as the man in the middle next season.
    Many had thought he would call it a day and settle into a retirement of watching his beloved Tranmere.
    But the return of fans next season could see him given something of a warm send-off from the stands.
    Dean started out in the Northern Premier League before moving up the divisions and reaching the top-tier in September 2000.
    His first Premier League game in charge saw the Wirral-born ref make a typically decisive call, refusing to award Southampton a late penalty in their 1-0 defeat to Leicester.
    Selected for Fifa’s international list in 2003, he took charge of European Championship qualifiers and the 2008 FA Cup final.
    Mike Dean has hit headlines from the stands too, showing his love for Tranmere Rovers
    Fans have often noted the more theatrical aspects of Dean’s performances including an apparent celebration of a Tottenham goal against Aston Villa in 2015.
    He would later explain that he was particularly pleased with an advantage awarded in the build-up to the goal.
    More recently, the veteran official has become one of the countless subjects of online abuse.
    Following controversial decisions to send off Southampton’s Jan Bednarek and West Ham’s Tomas Soucek, having reviewed the incidents on VAR, he was the target of horrific threats.
    CASINO SIGN UP OFFER: CLAIM UP TO £800 IN CASINO BONUS CASH

    Dean took a short break from the game and returned last month to make a typically gusty call in West Brom’s draw with Burnley.
    Writing for SunSport following the episode, Watford star Troy Deeney insisted players prefer his approach to officiating.
    The striker said: “When Dean is in charge of a match, what strikes you is how much he enjoys the game.
    “He is a proper football fan, supporting Tranmere Rovers, who is living the dream in the Premier League. He’s a good ref too, with 20 years of experience handling top matches and top players.”
    ⚽ Read our Football live blog for the very latest news from around the grounds
    Mark Halsey says VAR needs to improve after ref Mike Dean receives death threats after West Ham game More

  • in

    Referee who denied Cristiano Ronaldo goal vs Serbia ’embarrassed’ and ‘apologised’ to Portugal manager for huge blunder

    THE referee who denied Cristiano Ronaldo’s injury-time goal against Serbia admitted he was ’embarrassed’ and ‘apologised’ for his blunder.Ronaldo, 36, was left furious with Danny Makkelie and his Dutch team of officials when he failed to allow the clear winner.
    Cristiano Ronaldo was living with the officials after his winning ‘goal’ was not givenCredit: EPA
    Fernando Santos made his feelings clear to Danny Makkelie who later apologisedCredit: AP
    The Juventus forward tucked home under the goalkeeper and the ball clearly rolled over the line before Serb skipper Stefan Mitrovic hooked it away – and then saved the rebound.
    But with no goal-line technology, the goal did not stand.
    Ronaldo let rip at the assistant who did not flag – and was duly booked – but Portugal were left to settle for a 2-2 draw in their World Cup qualifier in Belgrade.
    And Fernando Santos, manager of the reigning European champs, revealed Makkelie recognised his costly gaffe.
    He told RTP: “We scored a goal that was not given when the ball went in. In a match of this level, that isn’t possible.
    “The referee apologised to me in the booth and told me he was embarrassed. I was in the dressing room with him and apologised to me.
    “He had told me on the pitch that he was going to see the images and that if it was the case he was calling me to apologise – and so it was.
    “I told him on the pitch that there was no VAR or goal-line technology – one of the things he told me was that the goal line was important – but I told him that the ball was half a metre inside the goal.
    FREE BETS: GET OVER £2,000 IN SIGN UP OFFERS HERE
    Replays showed the ball clearly crossed the line
    Cristiano Ronaldo is FUMING! 😡Portugal’s captain stormed off the pitch and threw his armband on the floor after he was denied a last-minute winner against Serbia…😳pic.twitter.com/BlwK9Dlque— Sky Sports Premier League (@SkySportsPL) March 28, 2021

    “There was no obstacle between the goalkeeper and the goal line. [It is a] problem because we drew. We have to rethink.
    “The referees are human and make mistakes, but that’s why there is the VAR and the goal-line technology to avoid this.”
    With the full-time whistle coming seconds later, Ronaldo ripped off his armband and launched it to the floor then stormed down the tunnel.
    The skipper posted a picture of the Portuguese team, for whom Diogo Jota scored twice, on Instagram with the caption: “Being captain of the Portugal team is one of the greatest privileges of my life.
    “I always give and will give everything for my country, that will never change.
    “But there are difficult times to deal with, especially when we feel that an entire nation is being harmed.
    “Lift your head and face the next challenge now! Strength, Portugal.”
    Ronaldo threw his captain’s armband to the ground in angerCredit: EPA
    Portugal’s players continued their protests after the full-time whistleCredit: AP
    Ronaldo was booked for berating the assistant referee who failed to flag for the goalCredit: Getty
    He was convinced he had done enough to secure an injury-time winner in BelgradeCredit: Getty

    Cristiano Ronaldo makes his thoughts very clear after being denied a late winner against Serbia More

  • in

    Refs’ chief Riley promises Prem clubs VAR will be ‘changed and improved’ next season after campaign of controversy

    REFS’ chief Mike Riley has promised Prem clubs that VAR will be “changed and improved” for next season.And Riley’s officials have agreed to undergo extra coaching and training in the summer to ensure VAR is more fit for purpose.
    Mike Riley has promised that VAR will be changed and improved next seasonCredit: PA:Empics Sport
    The vow by Riley came after Prem chiefs asked all clubs, including managers, and captains, for their feedback on how VAR has worked over the past two seasons.
    Clubs were sent video clips of controversial incidents from this season in a bid to get an understanding of how the top flight wants VAR to work.
    Crunch calls included the mistaken decision not to send off Everton’s Jordan Pickford for the late lunge that ended Virgil Van Dijk’s season in the Merseyside derby.
    VAR was criticised for the apparent inconsistency that saw Arsenal awarded a penalty in the North London derby but Liverpool keeper Alisson not penalised for a similar contact with Wolves’ Nelson Semedo the following day.
    There was also the remarkable decision not to award Manchester City’s Phil Foden a penalty when he was clearly tripped by Southampton keeper Alex McCarthy, with it later emerging the VAR match commander had intervened.
    It is hoped that the responses of the clubs will allow referee chiefs at PGMOL to apply the Laws more consistently from next term.
    Prem chiefs believe that making VAR work in a way that fits the game’s expectations of where and when officials should intervene will help bring about a change in perception of how the video system works.
    CASINO SIGN UP OFFER: CLAIM UP TO £800 IN CASINO BONUS CASH
    VAR has been a controversial subject throughout the Premier League seasonCredit: Reuters
    It is unlikely that there will be any changes to offside, however, as the International FA Board has insisted that ideas such as “wider lines” allowing “leeway” for attackers is not compatible with the Laws.
    In order to ensure all clubs have their views heard, the deadline for submissions was extended until Wednesday.
    That meant that a full discussion of the findings was put off until the next club meeting, which will be before the end of June.

    But clubs were told at the latest “shareholder” meeting Riley was planning to present an “action plan” which would outline “changes and improvements” that could be brought in from the start of next term.
    And that vow will be boosted by the pledge that all top flight officials and VAR teams will take the extra coaching and training during the summer.
    So far this season there have been 99 on-field decisions overturned by VAR, with 30 “goals” disallowed and 22 penalties awarded after intervention from Stockley Park.
    ⚽ Read our Football live blog for the very latest news from around the grounds
    Scott Parker says the game is becoming sterile as VAR kills football More

  • in

    Dutch legend Marco van Basten reveals radical plans to SCRAP offsides and would make football ‘more interesting’

    HOLLAND legend Marco van Basten wants to scrap the offside rule from football.The iconic former striker wants to do away with the rule as it will make the sport ‘more interesting’.
    Marco van Basten wants to bin the offside ruleCredit: Getty
    Van Basten, 56, was Fifa’s technical director between 2016 and 2018 and rule improvements were part of his remit.
    Legendary Arsenal boss Arsene Wenger is Fifa’s head of global development and launched his own offside overhaul to end VAR controversy last month.
    It would see a player being deemed ONSIDE if any part of the body which can legitimately score a goal is level or behind the last defender — even if other parts are in front.
    But Van Basten wants to go one step further and get rid of offsides altogether.
    The Dutchman told Sky Sports: “I am still very curious about the offside rule because I am convinced that it is not a good rule.
    “At least I would like to trial it to show that football is also possible without the offside rule. I am convinced that football would be better without it.
    “Football is a fantastic game but I still think that we have to do much more to make it better, more spectacular, more interesting, more exciting. We have to work on that.”
    Van Basten’s ideas would drastically change the way the sport is played but the former AC Milan star has thought it all through.
    FREE BETS: GET OVER £2,000 IN SIGN UP OFFERS HERE
    Arsene Wenger also wants to change the offside rule

    He added: “If you do away with the offside line then the defence will drop deeper. They will say that you cannot get behind us because they will be afraid of the opponents getting in behind.
    “But if you go too far back then the 18-yard box is going to become a melee and the goalkeeper will not be able to see anything, so teams will know it is not the solution.
    “As a result, the goalkeeper will want everybody out and that is exactly the point at which it would become so interesting.
    “If the attackers can move behind the defenders there are much more possibilities for goals. It will make the defending more difficult.
    ‘WE TALK ABOUT OFFSIDE DECISIONS A LOT’
    “On the other hand, when you are defending, if there is no offside, you can always have one or two players far away so that when you get the ball you can put it to your forwards in the other half.
    “The attacking team will have to be much more aware than they are now because the field is being made bigger.
    “When the field is made bigger there are much more options for the players in possession and for the trainers to come up with the best way to exploit that.
    “The problem now is that we do have offside and how often are we talking about the offside decisions? A lot.
    “If you do not have offside you have a lot less problems and the teams will still find other solutions to have a good game that will be just as spectacular as it is now but without this bad rule.
    “I am still very interested in it. It would just be nice to test it. I am sure football would find a way to become even more interesting.”
    ⚽ Read our Football live blog for the very latest news from around the grounds
    Haaland and Odegaard lead Norway stars in powerful human rights message before Gibraltar clash More

  • in

    Premier League clubs to hold talks over new VAR changes for next season with focus on handball and penalty decisions

    PREM club chiefs will help agree how to improve VAR next term when they meet virtually on Thursday.The latest meeting of the 20 ‘shareholder’ clubs is due to discuss the feedback from the survey commissioned by League bosses.
    VAR has caused much ire once again this seasonCredit: AP
    There have been 99 calls overturned by VAR this termCredit: PA
    Clubs have been given an extra 48 hours, until Wednesday to return their thoughts on a series of incidents that have taken place this season.
    Fans and players alike have voiced their frustrations over some crunch calls especially over defensive handballs and penalty decisions.
    It is hoped that the responses of players and managers will enable refs’ chief Mike Riley and his officials to agree on a consistent approach for the new campaign from August.
    League bosses and clubs accept that subjective refereeing calls mean there can never be 100 per cent consistency.
    But the aim is to give all officials clearer starting points for their decisions, either on the pitch or in the VAR booth at Stockley Park.
    So far there have been 99 on-field decisions in the Prem this season altered after VAR intervention.
    Liverpool have been the hardest hit, with a net six ‘goals’ chalked off, costing them four points.
    West Ham, by contrast, have gained four points from VAR decisions in their favour.
    PL TABLE WITHOUT VAR
    1 Man City 30 22 4 4 64 22 70 (=) -1
    2 Man Utd  29 16 8 5 59 34 56 (=) -1
    3 Leicester 29 16 7 6 54 32 55  (=) -1
    4 Liverpool  29 15 5 9 54 37 50 (+3) +4
    5 Chelsea  29 13 9 7 44 28 48 (-1) -3
    6 Tottenham 29 13 8 8 50 30 47 (=) -1
    7 Arsenal   29 13 6 10 43 32 45  (+2) +3
    8 West Ham 29 12 9 8 44 37 45 (-3) -4
    9 A Villa      28  12 7 9 43 32  43 (+1) +2
    10 Everton    28 13 4 11 40 39 43 (-2) -3
    11 Leeds       29 12 3 14 45 48 39 (=)  =
    12 C Palace  29  9 9 11 30 46 36 (=) -1
    13 Brighton   29 7 14 8 33 37 35  (+3) +3
    14 Wolves   29 8 10 11 31 37 34 (-1) -1
    15 Southampton 29 9 6 14 38 54 33 (-1) = 
    16 Burnley  29 8 8 13 22 39 32  (-1) -1
    17 Newcastle  29 7 6 16 27 46 28 (=) =
    18 Fulham 30 5 10 15 24 39 25 (=) -1
    19 WBA 29 3 10 16 21 56 19 (=) +1
    20 Sheff Utd 29 4 2 23 14 51 14  (=) =

    FREE BETS: GET OVER £2,000 IN SIGN UP OFFERS HERE

    Without VAR, Liverpool would have been fourth in the table, two points ahead of Chelsea, with the Hammers down in eighth.
    Brighton have three points fewer than they would have won without VAR, costing them three places in the table. The bottom four, though, are unchanged.   
    At the same stage last term there had been 81 changes, with the season’s aggregate of 109 overturns almost certain to be surpassed this time round.
    One of the reasons for the higher number was the initial hardline approach to handballs which was relaxed after Riley received dispensation from the International FA Board to be less doctrinaire.
    Ifab has now clarified that goals will only be ruled out next season if an accidental handball is committed by the scorer, while the Law-makers agreed that there is more margin for defenders to handle if they are in a ‘natural position’.
    ⚽ Read our Football live blog for the very latest news from around the grounds
    Scott Parker says the game is becoming sterile as VAR kills football More

  • in

    VAR shambles as chiefs with NO football experience ‘overruling Premier League referees at Stockley Park’

    VAR commanders with no authority in the Premier League are astonishingly over-ruling referees, it has been claimed.Former ref Mark Halsey has learned VAR Andy Madley was told by commander Adam Carter NOT to award Manchester City’s Phil Foden a blatant penalty against Southampton last week.
    VAR decisions are being taken out of experienced referees’ handsCredit: Getty Images – Getty
    On-field ref Jon Moss was not asked to review the incident on the pitch side monitor with a view to changing his original ruling, leaving boss Pep Guardiola to slam the decision as “incredible”.
    Halsey’s worrying claim will put the spotlight on Carter, who has never been a referee.
    Halsey, a Prem ref from 1999-2013, said: “I have been informed by reliable people involved in officiating about what is happening at Stockley Park regarding VAR decision-making.
    “The incident involving Phil Foden and Alex McCarthy was not deemed a penalty by on-field referee Jon Moss.
    “I have been told VAR Andy Madley thought it was a penalty and was about to recommend a review when Adam Carter got involved and told Madley that’s not a penalty.
    “The match commander should not be making decisions during a game.
    “Adam has never been a referee, he’s been an analyst.
    I feel for the officials in this situation. Now I know why VAR is all over the place and has drawn criticism.Mark Halsey
    “I understand the incident at City has been the talk of officials across the leagues over the past week. It makes me wonder, has this happened before? 
    “I feel for the officials in this situation. Now I know why VAR is all over the place and has drawn criticism from managers, players and fans for its inconsistency and rightly so.
    “The proof is in the pudding over how it has been operated for the last two seasons.”
    Play continued at the Etihad without a review in City’s 5-2 win over the Saints.
    The incident also led to Sky Sports pundit Graeme Souness furiously criticising the officials.
    He said: “They just make it up as they go along.
    “It is nonsense and they make themselves look stupid.”
    Phil Foden was not awarded a penalty against Southampton in controversial circumstancesCredit: PA
    Former Premier League referee Mark Halsey has revealed the course of decision making at Stockley ParkCredit: Getty Images – Getty
    VAR match commanders are allowed to be at Stockley Park with VAR officials, as was the case when Neil Swarbrick had an animated chat with Stuart Attwell in Leicester’s win over Wolves in November.
    But they should not be involved in the decision-making.
    In Germany, VAR project manager Hellmut Krug was removed from his position in 2017 amid claims he had influenced decisions in Schalke’s game with Wolfsburg.
    Krug denied he had any influence but lost his job days later.
    Carter, who was previously an assistant analyst at the PGMOL, is one of three matchday commanders – the others being former top-flight referee Swarbrick and former assistant ref Mike Mullarkey.
    FREE BETS: GET OVER £2,000 IN SIGN UP OFFERS HERE

    The Premier League has sent out a survey to clubs to canvass their opinions on VAR.
    It includes the question ‘to what extent do you support or oppose the use of VAR in the Premier League?’.
    One club source told us: “Do they really need the answer to that? We all know it’s not working.”
    ⚽ Read our Football live blog for the very latest news from around the grounds
    Scott Parker says the game is becoming sterile as VAR kills football More

  • in

    Prem stars invited to fix VAR shambles as league chiefs send survey to all clubs for feedback on system

    PREM stars are being quizzed on how they can fix the VAR mess.
    Surveys are being sent out to all 20 top-flight clubs in an unprecedented move by league chiefs.

    Premier League managers like Man City’s Pep Guardiola have openly blasted VARCredit: Rex Features

    Etihad star Phil Foden was denied what many thought was a blatant penalty against Southampton on Wednesday, highlighting the VAR controversyCredit: Getty Images – Getty

    Southampton keeper Alex McCarthy escaped punishment for what seemed a clear trip on Phil Foden during Man City’s midweek 5-2 winCredit: Rex Features

    And managers, captains and top brass will provide feedback on the system, which has been ridiculed all season.
    The shambles reached a new low on Wednesday after Manchester City’s Phil Foden was denied a stonewall penalty against Southampton.
    It sparked outrage from City chief Pep Guardiola, with fellow top-flight bosses rounding to blast VAR once again yesterday.
    League chiefs will now finally listen to their frustrations and surveys are expected to be returned by next Friday ahead of being discussed at the next shareholder meeting on March 25.

    Furious Guardiola claimed it was “incredible” VAR did not award  a penalty when Foden tried to stay on his feet after being taken out by keeper Alex McCarthy in the 5-2 win.
    And Burnley manager Sean Dyche believes the incident may prove to be a turning point for VAR.
    He said: “It’s truly bizarre. It amazes me in the modern game that you try to do the right thing and you get nothing, but when you do the wrong thing you get everything.
    “But maybe the Foden one might spark some interest because of the power of City — and rightly so with the level of the market that they’re at.

    “It’s only positive if they listen and change. It’s not positive if they don’t change. Getting some sort of feedback is necessary.”

    I’m not a lover of VAR. I don’t think I will be and I need convincing.”
    Fulham boss Scott Parker

    Sky Sports pundit Graeme Souness slammed the decision not to award City a penalty.
    He snapped: “These guys at Stockley Park must be having a toilet break. It is a nonsense, they look stupid.”
    Newcastle boss Steve Bruce added: “It was a stonewall penalty. It was brought in for the clear and obvious mistake a referee made and I don’t think we’ve got the balance right.”
    Clubs will be sent a series of clips of controversial calls and asked how they believe these incidents should have been judged.
    Fulham gaffer Scott Parker said: “I’m not a lover of VAR. I don’t think I will be and I need convincing.”
    Offside decisions will not be part of the survey because the Premier League are tied to the protocols of lawmakers Ifab.
    CHELTENHAM SPECIAL OFFER – GET THE FIRST RACE FAVOURITE AT HUGE 50/1 PRICE

    ⚽ Read our Football live blog for the very latest news from around the grounds
    The initiative is a joint idea agreed by Prem chiefs and refs’ boss Mike Riley, who has already consulted the Football Supporters’ Association.
    So far this season, there have been 97 decisions in the top-flight changed after VAR intervention.
    Refs have stuck with their original decisions on six occasions after being recommended to overturn.

    Scott Parker says the game is becoming sterile as VAR kills football More