More stories

  • in

    Premier League insist VAR screen did NOT break down when officials reviewed Man Utd penalty against Southampton

    THE Premier League have insisted the VAR screen did NOT break down when Mike Dean was reviewing his decision to award Manchester United a penalty against Southampton.
    Television footage showing the official trying to decide if Jan Bednarek had tripped Anthony Martial to concede the spot-kick appeared to suggest the pitchside monitor had frozen.

    Questions were raised over Mike Dean’s VAR review on Tuesday nightCredit: PA:Press Association

    Dean was seen frantically talking with his VAR Graham Scott as the screen stayed locked on one long distant frame – before he eventually decided to give the penalty and show Bednarek a red card.
    That led to confusion over how the referee was able to make a call when the video had not seemingly been working properly at Old Trafford.
    But the PGMOL have made it clear there was nothing wrong with the technology during the game.
    And instead Dean had asked video providers HawkEye to freeze the frame at the exact point of contact so he could assess the entire picture before making his decision.

    Bednarek was heard complaining ‘Martial said it’s not a foul!’ after the incident.
    Before the red card which led to United’s seventh goal, Southampton were left unhappy by a review that disallowed a Che Adams consolation.

    Jan Bednarek was adjudged to have made slight contact with Anthony MartialCredit: AP:Associated Press

    Dean handed the defender his marching orders with the score at 6-0Credit: Reuters
    The striker was deemed to be millimetres offside as Saints caught their opponents out with a free-kick routine.
    After the 9-0 drubbing, Southampton boss Ralph Hasenhuttl described the ‘horrible’ manner of the defeat.

    Aaron Wan-Bissaka, Marcus Rashford and Edinson Cavani scored before the break, alongside a Bednarek own goal.
    United then punished the visitors, who were down to ten men after 82 seconds, with goals from Scott McTominay, Bruno Fernandes and Daniel James after the break, as well as an Anthony Martial brace.
    FREE BETS: GET OVER £2,000 IN SIGN UP OFFERS HERE

    Likening the loss to last season’s 9-0 hammering at the hands of Leicester, Hasenhuttl said: “We lost again in a horrible way.
    “The same story, one man down [early] and so 90 minutes can be long. The lads had no alternatives – no players on the bench, no alternatives to defend better.
    “In the end, it’s a different situation to the first time, as it has been a good season so far and we are in a position we haven’t been for a long time [mid-table].
    “We know what we have to do better. It hurts more not less to have this result again. But the team is a different one now. Let’s see how the season ends.”
    ⚽ Read our Man United live blog for the latest news from Old Trafford

    Record equalling night at Old Trafford as Man Utd smash Southampton 9-0 More

  • in

    Liverpool would be SIX points clear at top of Premier League without VAR this season and Man Utd would drop place

    LIVERPOOL would have been SIX points clear and well on course to defend their Prem crown – if there was no VAR.
    Jurgen Klopp’s men are four points worse off than they would have been without the technology.

    Jurgen Klopp’s side are four points worse off with VARCredit: Tom Jenkins/ The Guardian

    And Manchester United, who can move clear at the top in the real world when they meet Burnley next week, would have been only third, some seven points adrift of the champions, without the interventions from Stockley Park.
    Liverpool have been the team on the “wrong” end of most VAR decisions, with eight overturns – either “factual” calls by Stockley Park or after the referee has looked at the pitchside monitor – compared to two changed decisions in their favour.
    While most of those calls only altered the scoreline, Klopp’s side lost four points that would have been banked without intervention.
    Those key decisions saw Jordan Henderson’s late “winner” in the Merseyside derby chalked off after Sadio Mane was deemed offside in the build-up and Brighton awarded an injury-time spot kick for Andy Robertson’s foul on Danny Welbeck at the Amex.

    United, by contrast, are three points better off than they would have been without VAR interventions.

    Liverpool’s VAR changes

    FOR
    Chelsea (a) Christensen yellow card upgraded to red 
    Wolves (h) Coady penalty overturned as no contact by Mane
    AGAINST
    Everton (A) Henderson goal ruled out for armpit offside against Mane
    Sheff Utd (h) Blades converted penalty after Fabinho foul ruled inside the box
    Sheff Utd (h) Salah goal offside
    West Ham (h) Jota goal disallowed for Mane foul
    Man City (a) Penalty for Gomez handball (missed by De Bruyne)
    Brighton (a) Salah offside goal in first half
    Brighton (a) Mane clearly offside from second half free-kick.
    Brighton (a) Gross scores penalty for Robertson foul on Welbeck

    Without the technology, United would have drawn at Brighton, rather than winning through a penalty awarded after the final whistle had initially been blown.
    And although United were denied what would have been a decisive spot kick in the Manchester derby, they would have lost 1-0 to West Brom, rather than beating them by the same score, if VAR had not been used.
    While they would have only been two points better off without VAR, Aston Villa have been arguably the biggest “victims” as Dean Smith’s side would have been four places higher and in fourth. 

    Up for the cup! Get Liverpool to beat Aston Villa at huge 35/1 price

    Jordan Henderson’s late winner was ruled out against EvertonCredit: Times Newspapers Ltd

    Man United are three points better off with VARCredit: PA:Press Association

    Despite two full rounds of games without a VAR overturn – the last changed decisions saw Tammy Abraham’s December 26 consolation strike for Chelsea at Arsenal allowed after being originally flagged offside – there have still been 65 changed decisions after 164 matches this term.
    Despite two full rounds of games without a VAR overturn – the last changed decisions saw Tammy Abraham’s December 26 consolation strike for Chelsea at Arsenal allowed after being originally flagged offside – there have still been 65 changed decisions after 164 matches this term.
    That equates to a changed decision every 2.52 matches. Last season, by comparison, the 380 matches brought 109 changes, at a rate of one every 3.49 games.
    A total of 21 goals have been disallowed, 17 of them for offside, three goals allowed that were initially flagged, 17 penalties awarded and nine waived, with 10 red cards after monitor reviews.

    Aston Villa vs Liverpool- Watch LIVE for FREE, channel info and kick-off time More

  • in

    EFL Carabao Cup VAR rules: Does League Cup use the Video Assistant Referee this season?

    The Carabao Cup has reached the semi-finals, but will VAR be making an appearance?
    The video referee system has proved controversial in the Premier League.

    VAR has become a regular feature in English footballCredit: PA:Press Association
    Does the Carabao Cup have VAR?

    From the semi-final stage up to the final, VAR WILL be used in the Carabao Cup.
    It has not been used in rounds up to the semi-finals this season.
    VAR was used in the Carabao Cup in 2018/19 but the EFL opted to get rid of the system last season on the grounds that it was only being used at Premier League venues.
    This caused particular controversy in the FA Cup when Man City were given a controversial penalty at Swansea and no VAR was allowed to be used even though the Liberty Stadium had the system installed.

    What decisions is VAR used for?
    THE video assistant referee can be called upon for four key on-field incidents. 
    These are:
    Awarding goals
    Penalty decisions
    Red card decisions
    Cases of mistaken identity
    How does VAR work?
    THE video assistant referee will liaise with the on-pitch referee to relay information on calls.
    The video assistant referee – a top official who will be based at Stockley Park for the matches – has access to every camera angle and goal-line technology cameras.

    The VAR also has an assistant watching the game with them. More

  • in

    Furious Aston Villa star Douglas Luiz tells refs to ‘use VAR CORRECTLY’ after conceding controversial penalty vs Man Utd

    FURIOUS Aston Villa star Douglas Luiz has ordered referees to ‘use VAR CORRECTLY’ after Manchester United’s controversial penalty during Friday’s game at Old Trafford.
    The Brazil midfielder, 22, gave away a crucial spot-kick after he was adjudged to have caught Paul Pogba in the box.

    Luiz was left furious after he was adjudged to have fouled Pogba

    Luiz appeared to have clipped Pogba but Villa boss Smith reckons the France star ‘tripped himself’Credit: AP:Associated Press

    With the game evenly poised at 1-1, Bruno Fernandes stepped up to score what turned out to be the match-winning penalty.
    Villa boss Dean Smith had already called the penalty ‘dubious’, suggesting Pogba had ‘tripped himself’.
    And Luiz has taken to Twitter to reveal his fury, clearly of the opinion ref Michael Oliver should have called for VAR.
    Luiz ranted: “I see this video, I can’t believe it was a penalty.

    ⚽ Read our Man United live blog for the latest news from Old Trafford
    “I always support fairer football, with fewer mistakes, but then I stop and see these types of moves.
    “If we have VAR to help, let’s start using it CORRECTLY.
    “These mistakes can define the future of clubs!”

    Luiz’s Twitter rant came shortly after his own boss called the decision into question.

    Luiz and boss Smith were both left outraged by the penalty decision after seeing the replayCredit: Reuters

    Speaking after the game, Smith said: “My view was it was a penalty from where I was stood.
    “I thought Douglas had got too tight with Pogba and he went down.
    “But I’ve just gone in the dressing room and seen it back and there’s a lot of doubt.
    “I think he’s tripped himself up.
    “Similar to Douglas when he was running back in the first half – he tripped himself up.
    “For me there’s enough doubt to send [Oliver] over the screen but he doesn’t get sent over to the screen.
    “I’m confused but I feel he tripped himself over.”
    Fernandes’ goal stole all three points for Man Utd and saw them draw level on points with league leaders Liverpool.
    In fact, Man Utd are TOP of the league based on games played since the Portuguese star arrived, three points clear of Liverpool.

    Paul Pogba ‘tripped himself’ for ‘dubious’ Man Utd penalty, claims Aston Villa chief Dean Smith More

  • in

    Fulham 0 Southampton 0: Che Adams misses open goal in huge blunder as VAR twice denies visitors

    LUCKY Scott Parker.
    The Fulham boss missed this clash and had to watch it from his sofa at home where he was self-isolating after a member of his family tested positive for Covid-19.

    Che Adams was unable to break the deadlock at a chilly Craven CottageCredit: AFP

    Theo Walcott had a late winner chalked off by VARCredit: AFP

    And while nobody wishes to be flippant about a global pandemic, you cannot help but feel he dodged a pretty bad fate here.
    Sitting in the warm, eating the last of the turkey would have been certainly preferable to sitting in the freezing cold at Craven Cottage watching this.
    The most wonderful time of the year it definitely was not as this clash epitomised Christmas for many.
    A lot of endeavour, expense, excitement and expectation ultimately resulted in nothing and left you wondering whether it was worth all the fuss in the first place.

    Fortunately for both clubs, this instantly forgettable clash did not come with a receipt or else those of us forced to witness it would have been exchanging it for a different one as soon as the shops reopen.
    Craven Cottage is widely regarded as one of English football’s quaintest venues.
    Though, rest assured, it was not so charming on Boxing Day as a biting wind and sleet swept in off the Thames through the gaps in the ground where the new £80million Riverside Stand is under construction.
    The new development is due to be ready by the start of next season – although given the conditions here, you cannot help but feel its rooftop plunge pool is a tad optimistic.

    Adams failed to finish off a huge chance in the first-halfCredit: Sky Sports

    The striker was then offside for the ruled-out winnerCredit: Sky Sports
    The magnificent new stand is not the only thing beginning to take shape at the Cottage.
    Parker’s squad, having picked up just one point from their opening six matches, appear to have turned a corner – with their only defeat in their previous six matches coming at Manchester City.
    This was the Cottagers’ fourth successive draw, while the Saints equalled a club record of seven consecutive top-flight away trips without a defeat.
    Ralph Hasenhuttl’s men have claimed 30 Premier League away points in 2020, a tally bettered only by Manchester United.
    The last time Fulham secured a Premier League victory on Boxing Day was a 2-1 win at Norwich in 2013 when Parker netted the clincher.
    They wasted their best chance here in the 25th minute when Ademola Lookman decided not to shoot after Ruben Loftus-Cheek had whipped in a brilliant cross from the right, and instead pulled the ball back to Andre-Frank Zambo-Anguissa, who completely missed his kick.
    Saints missed an even better opportunity seconds later when James Ward-Prowse’s stunning 25-yard free kick was kept out by a combination of Fulham keeper Alphonse Areola and woodwork, leaving Che Adams with the easiest of tasks to tap the bouncing loose ball into an empty net.
    But the striker froze like a Bernard Matthews turkey and could only watch in horror as the ball – and a certain goal – spun away from him.

    Fulham coach Matt Wells led from the touchline in Scott Parker’s absenceCredit: Getty – Pool

    The draw maintained both teams’ strong unbeaten runsCredit: Getty Images – Getty

    The second-half was not much better either, with Ivan Cavaleiro heading Antonee Robinson’s cross over the bar in the 56th minute.
    Areola then tipped Shane Long’s rising snap-shot over the bar.
    This game was so poor, not even VAR could save it as Ryan Bertrand’s cross for the visitors was adjudged NOT to have hit Fulham full-back Orla Aina’s arm in the penalty area.
    Long and Theo Walcott each had strikes ruled out for offside by video ref Jonathan Moss…
    VAR humbug!

    Theo Walcott makes emotional Southampton return 14-years after leaving for Arsenal in loan transfer from Everton More

  • in

    Carabao Cup VAR rules: Does League Cup use the Video Assistant Referee?

    The Carabao Cup has reached its quarter-final, but will VAR be making an appearance?
    The video referee system has proved controversial in the Premier League.

    VAR has become a regular feature in English footballCredit: PA:Press Association
    Does the Carabao Cup have VAR?

    VAR was used in the Carabao Cup in 2018/19.
    However, the EFL opted to get rid of the system last season on the grounds that it was only being used at Premier League venues.
    This caused particular controversy in the FA Cup when Man City were given a controversial penalty at Swansea and no VAR was allowed to be used even though the Liberty Stadium had the system installed.

    What decisions is VAR used for?
    THE video assistant referee can be called upon for four key on-field incidents. 

    These are:
    Awarding goals
    Penalty decisions
    Red card decisions
    Cases of mistaken identity
    How does VAR work?
    THE video assistant referee will liaise with the on-pitch referee to relay information on calls.
    The video assistant referee – a top official who will be based at Stockley Park for the matches – has access to every camera angle and goal-line technology cameras.
    The VAR also has an assistant watching the game with them. More

  • in

    Ex-Premier League ref David Ellery claims VAR IS working and making football better as it has stopped players diving

    FOOTBALL’S leading law-maker claims VAR has made football better – because players are no longer misbehaving.
    Former leading referee David Elleray is now the technical director of the International FA Board.

    Former Prem ref David Elleray insists VAR has made football better as players are no longer misbehavingCredit: Rex Features

    Elleray drafted the recent Law changes including stricter handball regulations.
    And while Elleray recognises the frustration of fans over stoppages while the technology cranks into gear, he is convinced that fewer rank bad calls, less diving and a reduction in harrassing officials are directly related to the advent of technology.
    Elleray said: “As a result of VAR there are now fewer games decided by clear and obvious errors by the match officials.
    “And there are fewer players getting away with violence on the field behind the referee’s back or indeed getting away with potential injury-threatening tackles which the referee hasn’t been able to judge correctly.

    “It’s also clear that VAR has had an impact on the flow of the game. 
    “Inevitably, if you are going to stop the game to look at a replay, that involves stopping the flow of the game.
    “I think some of the other benefits are less well publicised.
    “But there is evidence that there is a significant reduction in simulation in the penalty area.”

    The best available free agents still on the market

    He continued: “There’s also a general reduction in players mobbing and arguing with referees because they know very well that any contentious decision relating to a penalty or a goal is going to be checked or reviewed by the VAR.  So behaviour is better.”
    One unintended consequence of the latest tweak to the Laws has been a proliferation of penalty offences where VAR is used.
    Already this season, at the one-third mark of the Prem, there have been 54 penalties awarded, as opposed to 92 in the whole of last season.
    Elleray added: “Whether there are more penalties because of VAR – I think that’s an interesting debate. 
    “Somebody might need to do an analysis and say ‘how many of them were ‘stone-bonker’, if you like, penalties which were missed by the match officials – because we know the match officials can’t see everything.
    “We haven’t analysed that data as such but it’s clear that football is fairer.

    Crystal Palace star Andros Townsend wants the Premier League to scrap VAR now More

  • in

    Premier League release statement on why Son’s goal stood at Liverpool despite Tottenham star appearing offside

    THE Premier League have released a statement clarifying the offside debate surrounding Son Heung-min’s goal against Liverpool.
    South Korean star Son’s controversial first-half equaliser looked to have earned Spurs a draw at Anfield following Mohamed Salah’s opener.

    Liverpool boss Jurgen Klopp claimed Son Heung-min was offside

    Roberto Firmino ultimately powered home a 90th minute header to see the Reds leapfrog their visitors at the top of the table with a 2-1 win.
    But much of the post-match analysis still focused on Son – who had appeared from the naked eye to be offside in the buildup to his goal.
    Yet a VAR check determined the 28-year-old was marginally level before he received the ball and finished clinically past Liverpool stopper Alisson.
    Many fans questioned why in this particular instance the 3D crosshair lines were not used as they have been for most tight calls this season.

    And the Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL) have now released a statement to explain why that was the case.
    It read: “In the 33rd minute of Liverpool vs. Spurs, Son Heung-min scored for Spurs, the goal was checked for a possible offside by VAR.
    “The calibrated line was drawn from Liverpool defender Rhys Williams’ furthest point forward, his left foot, which showed that Son was behind him when the ball was played.
    “As both player’s feet were the furthest point forward and planted on the ground, the 3D crosshair lines were not required.”

    Despite the referees ruling the goal would stand, Liverpool boss Jurgen Klopp still insisted that Son was offside.
    He said: “For me, it is offside [the Spurs goal], they watch it 20 times, but when I saw it, it is offside.
    “There is nobody to blame, the best way to defend Tottenham is to keep the ball all the time.”

    Jurgen Klopp says it was a massive three points against Tottenham after last minute 2-1 win More