More stories

  • in

    Dave Kidd: VAR does NOT need to be reformed, it should be SCRAPPED… and Calvert-Lewin red was the breaking point

    DCL, VAR, WTF! Sometimes one single incident is so absurd that it has the capacity to bring down an entire house of cards.And when Everton striker Dominic Calvert-Lewin was handed a straight red card in Thursday’s FA Cup third-round clash with Crystal Palace, VAR might just have reached its breaking point.
    Dominic Calvert-Lewin was sent off by VAR for this challenge on ThursdayCredit: Getty
    Referee Chris Kavanagh was showed slow-motion footage when called over the the VAR screenCredit: AFP
    Calvert-Lewin executed an excellent tackle on Palace’s Nathaniel Clyne, top-flight referee Chris Kavanagh correctly judged that the challenge was not even a foul and yet, 30 seconds later, he was sent to his monitor and advised to dismiss the England forward.
    There was no ‘excessive force’ in the challenge, Calvert-Lewin was not ‘endangering an opponent’ and he actually won the ball with a neat piece of skill close to the Palace box.
    Yet not just one but TWO Premier League referees, in the VAR hub at Stockley Park, decided Kavanagh had made a ‘clear and obvious error’.
    Then the on-field ref — provoked by slow-motion replays — failed to trust his own judgment and refused to uphold his original decision.
    Read More Football News
    To add to this farce, VAR is in operation for FA Cup matches played at Premier League stadiums and not for those hosted by EFL clubs.
    Yet for those games staged at top-flight clubs, such as Palace, ‘support VARs’ have also been appointed, meaning VAR Craig Pawson was assisted by Michael Salisbury.
    This undermines the often-stated lie by VAR cheerleaders that ‘it is not the technology but the personnel’ which is to blame for the system’s disastrous application.
    Because the fact is that the more human beings that are involved in any decision, the greater the capacity for human error.
    Most read in Football
    FREE BETS – BEST BETTING OFFERS & NEW CUSTOMER BONUSES
    VAR must now be scrapped, says Dave KiddCredit: Reuters

    Too many cooks spoil the broth. Too many referees spoil a football match. Now Palace v Everton was a stinker, which ended 0-0 despite Sean Dyche’s side being reduced to ten men.
    And presumably Calvert-Lewin’s three-match ban for a straight red will be rescinded on appeal.
    But while minimal harm was done, this was the clearest possible case of VAR not just failing to improve decision-making but making it actively worse.
    The Luis Diaz offside decision which sentenced Liverpool to their only Premier League defeat of the season at Tottenham in October was more damaging and more ridiculous.
    Too many cooks spoil the broth. Too many referees spoil a football match. Dave Kidd
    But that was a catastrophic one-off failure of process from VAR Darren England, which led to an incorrect on-field decision being upheld.
    The Calvert-Lewin incident was a glaring example of how slow-motion replays persuade highly experienced referees to disbelieve their own eyes.
    And of how the procedure of a VAR sending a referee to his monitor is a charade, given that 99 per cent of the time, this leads to an on-field official overturning his decision.
    Perhaps the Calvert-Lewin incident will lessen, or even end, the use of slo-mo replays.
    But what we really need is for pundits and prominent journalists to stop parroting the phrase ‘VAR will never be scrapped’.
    These are invariably people who never pay to attend matches and fail to fully comprehend how VAR interferes with the joyful spontaneity of football — a sport in which so many refereeing decisions are subjective, meaning the idea of absolute justice will always be impossible.
    Why can’t VAR be scrapped?
    And how is it helpful to keep saying ‘VAR will never be scrapped’, when most people want it scrapped and it absolutely could be scrapped.
    Arguing against technology does not automatically make you a member of the Flat Earth Society howling at the moon.Dave Kidd
    This is an extension of a dangerous ‘computer says no’ culture.
    Just watch ITV1’s brilliant drama Mr Bates v The Post Office to understand the extraordinary scale of human misery caused by a faulty computer system — and by the inability of apparently sensible people to believe that technology can possibly be wrong.
    Likewise, try to get some common sense out of Barclays Bank over their draconian mortgage policies.
    Organisations like the Post Office and Barclays destroy people’s lives by following a ‘computer says no’ mantra.
    Read more on The Sun
    VAR only destroys football matches. But the principle is the same.
    Until we realise that arguing against technology does not automatically make you a member of the Flat Earth Society howling at the moon, then we will never reach the blindingly obvious conclusion that VAR does not need to be reformed, it must be scrapped. More

  • in

    Footie love rat lies about age & height on dating profile after affair with dominatrix destroyed his relationship

    FOOTIE love-rat Jermaine Pennant has been caught offside again — fibbing about his age and height as he hunts for dates.The ex-Liverpool star, dumped by his reality TV partner for cheating with a dominatrix in May last year, says on his Hinge profile that he is 34.
    Jermaine Pennant has been caught offside yet again — with fibs spotted on a dating app profileCredit: Rex Features
    His Hinge profile states he has lost six years and gained two inchesCredit: Supplied
    But he has lost six years — he was born in January 1983 and will be 41 in nine days.
    The 5ft 8in former winger also wrongly lists his height as 5ft 10in.
    There is also no mention of his colourful personal life, including a string of broken relationships, allegations of cheating and his self-confessed reluctance to be faithful.
    A source said: “Jermaine has a cheeky side to him but lying about his age and height is not a great start when he’s trying to impress women.”
    READ MORE ON JERMAINE PENNANT
    The talkSPORT pundit is looking for dates again after we revealed last month that he had split from TV star Jess Impiazzi, 34.
    She was told by pals that he had taken the flame-haired dominatrix to his hotel room during a stag do in Ibiza.
    But he seems to have forgotten his wild ways on his Hinge profile in which he lists his simple pleasures as “sofa, movie, wine”.
    He may also be understating it a little when he asks potential hook-ups, “Don’t be boring live a little.”
    Most read in Football
    Jermaine, who has appeared on Celebrity SAS and Celebrity Big Brother, also shares a series of holiday snaps in which he is decked out in shorts, a shirt and sunglasses.
    Another sober image shows him in a smart suit and tie.
    But if anyone takes him on, they might struggle to tame one of football’s wildest spirits.
    At 15, he was sold by Notts County to Arsenal for £2million — a then-record for a trainee.
    His career never quite reached the expected heights and in 2005 he was jailed for drink-driving and played while electronically tagged.
    Off the field, he dated glamour models and actresses — but, by his own admission, struggled to remain faithful.
    In January last year, he was declared bankrupt and living in Jess’s apartment in Surrey.
    Friends hoped he was finally settling down and the couple were having fertility treatment as they tried for a baby.
    Read more on The Sun
    Jess, who appeared in Towie and Ex on The Beach, even tried to move on from his alleged stag do fling in Ibiza — but said she soon suspected he was sending flirty messages to other women and ended their two-year relationship.
    In 2022, Jermaine revealed he had ADHD, which he blamed for his impulsive actions.
    Reality star Jess Impiazzi split from Jermaine after she suspected he was sending flirty messages to other womenCredit: PA
    Jermaine previously played for LiverpoolCredit: Getty More

  • in

    Karren Brady: It’s a case of Deja Roo as Wayne Rooney follows England pals Gerrard and Lampard onto managerial scrapheap

    WITHOUT question the most important item on a football club agenda is the choice of manager, more fashionably a head coach.The team will stand or fall by this decision. Wayne Rooney at Birmingham was the latest to confirm that getting the chop could also be as brutally swift as the slide of the guillotine.
    Wayne Rooney was given the boot by Birmingham after a horror run of formCredit: Reuters
    He must have been aware that it might. After all, it had happened to two of his former England team-mates, Steven Gerrard and Frank Lampard, who found that being great footballers was no defence against managerial botch-ups.
    Rooney was the last of the turn-of-century Three Musketeers to slip off the manager’s saddle, after only two wins in 15 Championship games.
    Vastly popular at Everton and Manchester United, the rest of the country wasn’t far behind in delight at his ability to score stacks of goals combined with thrilling ball skills.
    Birmingham fans were just as admiring, at least until the new American owners accompanied his appointment by ruthlessly sacking the relatively successful John Eustace, a local boy, after he led them to sixth in the Championship.
    Read More Football
    There can be fewer jobs as stressful, unpredictable and unrelenting than being a football boss where only two things are guaranteed — the sack or a move to a bigger club.
    The man in charge must be trusted by players, staff and chairman. He has to be deeply knowledgeable in all things football. And most of all he must be a leader.
    The fact that he was a great footballer hardly matters.
    So where did our golden boys go wrong? My guess is that, above all, the players didn’t get it. Simply weren’t on the same wavelength.
    Most read in Football
    Liverpool legend Steven Gerrard is feeling the heat – managing out in SaudiCredit: Getty
    CASINO SPECIAL – BEST CASINO WELCOME OFFERS
    I remember an England player telling me that in training their star man was challenged by the coach to hit the bar from 15 yards out.
    He tried twice and failed.
    The coach placed the ball in the same spot and struck the bar first time. “Easy as that,” he said, striding away.
    The victim was undermined. And the coach didn’t last too long.
    Is it fair to say that Rooney seemed the most unlikely of the three to make an outstanding manager? But you never know.
    Did mouthy Brian Clough strike many people as a possible double European Cup winner?
    I am told by football oracles that Rooney did a sound job at Derby and his trouble at St Andrew’s was introducing a fresh style too quickly.
    Birmingham City have enormous potential. The way forward is by meticulous planning and an ambitious boss of humbler origin is crucial, unless Pep Guardiola is up for a new challenge.
    Read more on The Sun
    Had they studied a list of previous appointments, they would have been aware of a similar farce at the club when Gary Rowett was axed for Gianfranco Zola in 2016.
    The Italian star lasted slightly longer than Rooney. Not so much ‘deja vu’ as ‘deja Blues’.
    Frank Lampard has not found managing as easy as he seemed to make playingCredit: Getty More

  • in

    Sunderland footballer Jack Diamond claims he refused sex with rape accuser after she ‘got on top of me’

    A CHAMPIONSHIP footballer accused of raping a woman told a court that he had refused sex with her.Sunderland winger Jack Diamond, 23, told a jury that his alleged victim was in a “huff” when he told her to stop after she “got on top of me”.
    Sunderland footballer Jack Diamond claims he refused sex with rape accuser after she ‘got on top of me’Credit: NCJMedia
    Diamond denied rape and assault by penetration at Newcastle crown courtCredit: Getty
    He explained that he did so because he feared things were “getting a bit too serious”.
    Diamond, who had previously been in a long relationship, said he kissed her later to “comfort” her and she told him, ‘I think the moment has gone’ and left.
    The footballer, who met the girl on dating site Tinder, is alleged to have attacked her at the home he shared with team-mate Anthony Patterson.
    He said he did feel regretful about his “immaturity” towards relationships at the time.
    READ MORE UK NEWS
    Diamond, of Washington, Tyne & Wear, denies rape and assault by penetration at Newcastle crown court.
    The trial continues. More

  • in

    Footie fan stripped of season ticket in three-year ban after sick taunt about Munich air crash

    A FOOTBALL fan was today banned from matches for three years for a sick taunt about the Munich air disaster which went viral.Newcastle United supporter James Blake, 42, “photobombed” a YouTuber’s report at the club’s Carabao Cup clash with Manchester City in September.
    A clip went viral of Newcastle United supporter James Blake making a sick taunt about the 1958 Munich air crash, in which eight Manchester United players diedCredit: North News & Pictures
    Blake — who had been drinking heavily and was wearing a replica Newcastle shirt — yelled: “Hello! What about Man United, eh? Air disasters, air disasters.”
    Prosecutor Steven Davis said: “You will see a person address the camera when he is approached from behind by a man and a young child and he makes the comment.”
    Eight Manchester United players were among 23 people who died in 1958 when a plane crashed during take-off in then-West Germany.
    Painter and decorator Blake was stripped of his season ticket by Newcastle after his arrest.
    READ MORE BEAUTIFUL GAME
    Dave Parish, mitigating, said: “He is deeply remorseful and frankly ashamed by this behaviour.
    “He accepts he was highly intoxicated at the time.”
    Blake, of North Shields, admitted using threatening or abusive words or behaviour likely to cause harassment, alarm or distress at North Tyneside magistrates’ court.
    He was fined £400, ordered to pay a total of £780 and banned for three years from all football matches in England and Wales.
    Most read in Football
    23 people died when a plane took off in then-West Germany, with eight of them being Manchester United playersCredit: PA More

  • in

    Jack Grealish burglars tried to raid mansion a month before £1m attack but were scared off

    BURGLARS responsible for the £1million raid on Jack Grealish’s mansion were scared off by cops a month earlier, we can reveal.The gang got spooked when a police car drove past as they prepared to break in.
    BURGLARS responsible for the £1million raid on Jack Grealish’s mansion were scared off by cops a month earlier, we can revealCredit: Getty
    Sasha Attwood, pictured with Man City and England ace Jack, was in at the time of the raid and raised the alarm but the gang escaped after less than three minutesCredit: Instagram
    They first targeted the Man City midfield ace’s £5.6million mansion while he played against RB Leipzig on November 28 in the Champions League.
    But they did not know Grealish, 28, and girlfriend Sasha Attwood, 27, were yet to move in.
    They fled the scene when a police car coincidentally cruised by as they lay in wait down a quiet village lane near Knutsford, Cheshire.
    They returned on December 27, grabbing watches and gems worth £1million while Jack played in City’s 3-1 win at Everton.
    READ MORE ON THE RAID
    Sasha and members of Jack’s family were in at the time and raised the alarm but the gang escaped after less than three minutes, according to an underworld source.
    They said the burglary was carried out with the approval of a Salford gang and the stolen items will be sold in Spain.
    They added: “These lads are good at what they do. They never spend longer than a couple of minutes in a house because they automatically assume an alarm has been triggered the moment they gain entry. They don’t want to hurt or threaten anyone as they know that will increase their jail sentence if they are caught.”
    Police are probing whether the raid was an inside job linked to other targeted footie stars. The source said: “If you’re a tradesman and work for footballers, once in with one you’re in with them all as they pass them on to teammates and say, ‘Use my guy’.
    Most read in Football
    “So the police are trying to see if there is any pattern of a tradesman or particular company working at burgled properties.”
    A Cheshire Police spokesman said: “No arrests have been made at this time and enquiries are ongoing.” More

  • in

    Man City ace Erling Haaland sells private plane worth £3million

    ERLING Haaland has stopped playing on the wing this season — after selling his private plane.The Man City star, 23, has been snapped all over Europe on board the Piper Malibu, which he owned with former footie international dad Alfie, 51, and two partners.
    Erling Haaland has stopped playing on the wing this season — after selling his private planeCredit: PA
    The Piper M600 is now £3million to buy newCredit: Piper
    But Norwegian striker Haaland has ditched the plane which cost just under £2million in 2021.
    The buyer, gun silencer tycoon Eckhoff Johansen, 47, said he had paid substantially more than the 2021 price.
    The Piper M600 is now £3million to buy new.
    Haaland and his dad held a 37.5 per cent stake in the company which owned the six-seater.
    Read More on Football
    A source told The Sun: “Erling and Alfie have had fun in their plane.
    “But they’re both multi-millionaires who can ­afford to charter a ­private plane without the hassle of ownership.”
    “It’s a bonus that they appear to have sold it for more than they paid for it – that’s good business!”
    Haaland has spent Christmas recovering from a stress injury to his foot which has kept him out of the City side for weeks.
    Most read in Football More

  • in

    Ex-England captain Sol Campbell sued for more than £800k after pulling out of buying £3.85m flat

    EX-England captain Sol Campbell is being sued for more than £800,000 after pulling out of buying a £3.85million flat.Sol, 49, and wife Fiona had put a ten per cent (£387,500) deposit down on the home in London’s swish Cadogan Square.
    Sol Campbell is being sued for more than £800,000 after pulling out of buying a multi-million pound flatCredit: Getty
    The flat’s owner Lady Jadranka Beresford-Peirse has lodged papers at the High Court which claim the pair signed a contract to buy in 2021 but failed to pay the balance due.
    Widow Lady Jadranka is seeking a total of about £810,000 in alleged losses and new sale costs.
    Ex-Spurs and Arsenal defender Sol played 73 times for England.
    Campbell then went on to manage Macclesfield Town and Southend United.
    READ MORE FOOTBALL NEWS
    He married interior designer Fiona Barratt, granddaughter of Barratt Homes founder Sir Lawrie Barratt, in 2010.
    Lady Jadranka now accuses Sol and Fiona Campbell of breach of contract, saying they failed to pay the balance due for the flat, and threatened to sue them for specific performance of the contract if they failed to go ahead with the deal.
    She is seeking an order which would force them to have to buy the flat and pay her compensation.
    Lady Jadranka is seeking an order that would force him and his wife to have to buy the flat and pay her compensation.
    Most read in Football
    She claims she lost £260,000 after being unable to go ahead with her purchase of a smaller flat. More