More stories

  • in

    Man Utd stars desperate for Ruud van Nistelrooy to stay on after Ruben Amorim takes control at Old Trafford

    MANCHESTER United’s first team squad are desperate for interim manager Ruud van Nistelrooy to stay on after Ruben Amorim takes over in the Old Trafford dugout. The players are united in their belief that Amorim should make the United legend part of his backroom squad after growing close to him since he was brought back to the club in the summer by sacked manager Erik ten Hag.Van Nistelrooy is desperate to stay on as Man Utd assistant managerCredit: GettyRuben Amorim is set to be the new Man Utd managerCredit: GettyVan Nistelrooy was appointed assistant manager and quickly formed a bond with the squad, who regarded him as easier to communicate with than ten Hag, would could blow hot and cold with players.The former striker – who scored 150 goals in 219 games during Sir Alex Ferguson’s reign – became a vital link between ten Hag and the players.A source said: “The players all really really want Ruud to stay on and have made their feelings clear internally that they believe he should remain at the club, even if and when Amorim takes over as boss.“To a man, they all like him and get on with him and they also respect him because they know he undertands what it’s like to play for United and the pressures that come with it.READ MORE MAN UTD NEWS“They are hopeful that he stays involved in the setup.”Van Nistelrooy stepped in as interim manager on Monday after United sacked ten Hag following a 2-1 loss at West Ham, which left them 14th in the Premier League.He inspired the team to a rousing 5-2 victory over Leicester in the Caraboa Cup on Wednesday and will be in charge on Sunday as they take on Chelsea at Old Trafford.Speaking ahead of Sunday’s game, Van Nistelrooy made clear he hopes to remain at United.Most read in FootballCASINO SPECIAL – BEST CASINO WELCOME OFFERSHe said: “I decided to come back here for a very important reason.“I came as an assistant to help the club move forward.Sporting fans give verdict on Ruben Amorim ahead of move to Man Utd“It’s going to be a short job as an interim – that was communicated very clear.“I was happy with that. I will then go back to my assistant contract that I have here for this season and next.“When a new manager signs and conversations take place we have to see how things develop.”Amorim is not expected to start at United for another ten days, meaning Van Nistelrooy is likely to be in charge for Thursday’s Europa League clash against PAOK and then again for the Premier League game against Leicester on November 10.Amorim has promised to speak about his future after Sporting Lisbon’s game against Estrela Amadora tonight.Why NOBODY is the right man to replace Erik ten Hag at Man UtdSunSport’s DAVE KIDD explains what’s wrong with all the potential candidates to replace Erik ten Hag at Manchester United.THIS is a mid-table squad at an underachieving club, with a lot of unwanted players on big money.And Ratcliffe is an instinctive cost-cutter who may not pay top dollar to the next manager.If this club wasn’t called ‘Manchester United’, it wouldn’t be an especially desirable job.The good news for United is that their new sporting director, Dan Ashworth, is a very decent judge of a manager.He has been instrumental in three previous managerial appointments — Gareth Southgate for England, Graham Potter for Brighton and Eddie Howe for Newcastle.None were wildly popular at the time, all were conspicuous successes.Interestingly, Ashworth’s No 1 choice for the Newcastle job was Unai Emery, who turned him down to stay at Villarreal but has since proved that judgment right by excelling at Aston Villa.And the Spaniard would be an excellent fit for United — yet there is next to no chance that he would abandon Villa’s Champions League campaign to take the Old Trafford job, not least because he isn’t a stark raving madman.Howe would be another good candidate to succeed Ten Hag but, although he has become frustrated on Tyneside, the Saudis would surely not allow Ratcliffe to poach Howe, as they reluctantly did with Ashworth.Potter is available but his Chelsea experience and lack of charisma would make him a tough sell.Which brings us to Southgate, who remains close with Ashworth and is an excellent man-manager who was seriously considered by United last spring.Yet, despite having led England to two of their three major finals, Southgate’s reputation for over-caution was only enhanced during the Euros.Mauricio Pochettino, passed over twice by United, is out of the equation having taken the United States job.Thomas Tuchel would also have been a popular and gettable option – but England got in there first.Likewise, Roberto De Zerbi, now at Marseille after his brief Brighton stint sparkled then fizzled out.Kieran McKenna — a gifted former United coach who has won back-to-back promotions with Ipswich Town — is an intriguing candidate but the imminent vacancy may come a year or so too soon.Marco Silva, the extremely under-rated Fulham boss, has been on United’s radar and should not be discounted.Sporting Lisbon’s Ruben Amorim, last season’s ‘next big thing’, was passed over by West Ham as well as Liverpool this summer and is not an easy man to pin down.Zinedine Zidane, who has taken over from Alan Curbishley as a 20-1 shot for every Premier League job, is a ‘figurehead’ manager and not an Ashworth type.Ruud van Nistelrooy, the former United goal machine who joined Ten Hag’s coaching team in the summer is the bookies’ favourite. Simply because he’s in the building and he’s Dutch.So, yes, getting rid of Ten Hag is the easy part. More

  • in

    Dan Ashworth ‘getting revenge on Newcastle’ as ‘Man Utd analyst forced to do gardening leave before switching to rivals’

    DAN ASHWORTH is reportedly getting revenge on Newcastle in their pursuit of a Manchester United analyst.The United sporting director was forced into a period of gardening leave when he decided to swap Newcastle for Old Trafford in February.Dan Ashworth is reportedly getting his revenge on NewcastleCredit: PAAshworth did not officially start his role at Old Trafford until June, after United and Newcastle agreed a compensation package.Now the shoe is on the other foot with Newcastle chasing United analyst Luke Dickson.Earlier this year Dickson reportedly told his United bosses he wanted to leave to take a job at Newcastle.But United chiefs told Dickson he would not be able to start his new role at St. James’ Park until November, according to the Daily Mail.READ MORE ON MAN UTDThe blockage reportedly frustrated key figures at Newcastle who viewed the move as a tit-for-tat response to Ashworth’s attempt to leave the club.Dickson, 28, has spent five years at Old Trafford as the club’s lead academy analyst and had to see out the remainder of his contract on gardening leave.Newcastle is his boyhood club and Dickson is set to join Eddie Howe’s first-team set-up.Ashworth, 53, left Newcastle on bad terms after he reportedly revealed his secret talks with United chief executive Omar Berrada.Most read in FootballBEST FREE BET SIGN UP OFFERS FOR UK BOOKMAKERSThe pair are alleged to have held a conversation at the start of February which led to Ashworth following it up by sending Berrada an email to an Ineos account.He is claimed to have made it clear he wanted to accept the chance to become sporting director at United.Danny Welbeck lifts lid on ex-Man Utd players’ WhatsApp group including one huge star who just ‘chats and chats’ However, Ashworth “clumsily” disclosed to his employers the negotiations with Berrada by sending a blind copy to his own Newcastle club email account at a time when United had not informed Toon of their interest. More

  • in

    Ten Hag ‘wanted to bring former Man Utd striker back to Old Trafford’ in desperate bid to solve goalscoring woes

    ERIK TEN HAG reportedly wanted Manchester United to re-sign Danny Welbeck this summer in a desperate attempt to solve the club’s attacking woes.The Dutchman was sacked by United on Monday following a poor start to the season.Erik ten Hag wanted to sign a former United striker this summerCredit: ReutersDanny Welbeck was among Ten Hag’s transfer targetsCredit: GettyWelbeck graduated from United’s academy and remained at the club until 2014Credit: Getty – ContributorHis departure came just 116 days after he signed a one-year contract extension.Club officials gave Ten Hag around £200million to spend in the transfer window after he extended his deal.He went on to sign Matthijs De Ligt, Noussair Mazraoui, Manuel Ugarte, Leny Yoro, Joshua Zirkzee and Sekou Kone.But Sir Jim Ratcliffe and Co did not entertain his desire to sign former United ace Welbeck.Read More in FootballAccording to The Athletic, Ten Hag believed the Brighton striker would be an “excellent” addition to his squad.The 33-year-old’s name was brought up in recruitment discussions at the end of the 2023-24 campaign.He was heading towards free agency, with his Brighton deal set to expire in June.Ten Hag and his team saw Welbeck’s experience as a positive for the dressing room.Most read in FootballFOOTBALL FREE BETS AND SIGN UP DEALSThey were also impressed that he ranked among the top performers at Brighton based on physical tests.But a concrete offer for the ex-England striker – who previously scored 29 goals in 142 appearances for United – did not materialise.’Something seriously wrong!’ Ex-Prem ref reacts to huge Man Utd call which saw Erik Ten Hag sackedInstead, he penned a new two-year contract with Brighton.Welbeck has since scored six goals in nine Premier League appearances this season, with Brighton sixth in the table.Meanwhile, United are down in 14th with 11 points from nine games.Sporting Lisbon manager Ruben Amorim is in line to replace Ten Hag at Old Trafford.He will reportedly join during the November international break – which starts on Monday, November 11. More

  • in

    Man Utd and Chelsea ‘line up stunning Vinicius Jr transfer swoop’ after Real Madrid star snubs talks over new contract

    MANCHESTER UNITED and Chelsea are among several clubs eyeing a future move for Real Madrid superstar Vinicius Jr, according to reports.The Brazilian, 24, has had another stunning year in Spain, and was widely expected to win the Ballon d’Or before being pipped by Rodri.Vinicius Jr will have two years remaining on his contract at the end of the seasonCredit: RexVinicius Jr remains under contract in the Spanish capital until 2027.But according to Spanish outlet Relevo, the winger recently snubbed fresh contract talks – putting several clubs on alert.Among his potential suitors are claimed to be Premier League duo Man Utd and Chelsea.But both sides would face stiff competition, even if Real were to entertain selling their star man.READ MORE IN FOOTBALLAlso interested are French champions Paris Saint-Germain.Real Madrid have a strained relationship with PSG chiefs, given their protracted pursuit of Kylian Mbappe over several years.The Ligue 1 side would love to get back at Real Madrid by prising away Vinicius Jr in similar circumstances.Real chiefs are said to be desperate to avoid this situation.Most read in FootballBEST FREE BET SIGN UP OFFERS FOR UK BOOKMAKERSVinicius Jr also has significant interest in Saudi Arabia.During the summer, the Public Investment Fund were claimed to have made an eye-watering proposal.Watch Jude Bellingham’s expletive-laden instructions to Mbappe and Co at half-time of Real Madrid drawThe deal would have seen Vinicius Jr sign for Al-Ahli, earning a staggering €1bn (£843.98m) across five seasons.Real Madrid are determined to hold onto their star man long-term and are eager to demonstrate how much they value him.But for now, contract talks remain on hold.Vinicius Jr has won three LaLiga titles, two Champions Leagues, a Copa del Rey and two Club World Cups with Real Madrid.Last season he scored 24 goals and laid on 11 assists in all competitions, with figures across his club preparing for him to win the Ballon d’Or.He was said to be “devastated” after missing out – cancelling a huge party, with Real Madrid also snubbing the entire bash in solidarity. More

  • in

    Danny Welbeck lifts lid on ex-Man Utd players’ WhatsApp group including one huge star who just ‘chats and chats’

    DANNY WELBECK has revealed he is part of a WhatsApp group of former Manchester United players.The Brighton striker came through the academy at United and played for the first team between 2008 and 2014.Danny Welbeck revealed he is part of a WhatsApp group of former Red DevilsCredit: Sky SportsThe striker shared who the chattiest member isCredit: GettyHe scored 29 goals in 142 appearances for the club before a switch to Arsenal, but he is still in touch with some of his former team-mates.Welbeck revealed he is a member of a WhatsApp group consisting of former United stars.Discussing the group, he told Sky Sports: “Everybody plays a part. It’s a lot of banter, chatting about football and a lot of banter.”Asked who the admin is, Welbeck replied: “I think it might be Rio [Ferdinand].READ MORE ON MAN UTD”He just chats doesn’t he. You know what he’s like he just chats and chats.”He loves it. He’s making a career out of talking now so…we give me a lot of stick too.”Welbeck is enjoying his most productive season to date with six goals in nine Premier League games.He is just four goals away from recording his best goalscoring season and has helped Brighton up to sixth place.Most read in FootballBEST FREE BET SIGN UP OFFERS FOR UK BOOKMAKERSWelbeck has found the net in each of his last three games despite being stretchered off and requiring oxygen against Newcastle two weeks ago.Brighton boss Fabian Hurzeler is getting the best out of Welbeck and he was full of praise for his striker.Ruud van Nistelrooy hints he wants to stay at Man Utd in plea to Ruben Amorim as interim vows to ‘serve’ clubHe said: “I don’t judge him just by goals and assists, honestly for me it’s more about how he works for the team.“He’s the perfect role model and you can only do it every week when you behave professionally.” More

  • in

    Fans say ‘he’s still got it’ as De Gea bags MOTM award after string of stunning saves as ex-Man Utd ace’s stats go viral

    DAVID DE GEA has “still got it” after performing heroics for Fiorentina. The Spaniard joined the Serie A side in August having spent a season as a free agent after leaving Manchester United. David de Gea’s stunning save against GenoaCredit: XBut the former Red Devils stopper, 33, has not missed a step and produced a Man of The Match performance against Genoa. De Gea made a string of sensational saves, the best of the lot coming after tipping Johan Vasquez’s header over the bar. Incredible stats revealed he is now first in save percentages, second in stops made over 90 minutes, sixth in goals prevented with three clean sheets. Fiorentina are also on a six-match unbeaten streak with De Dea between the posts as one said: “He’s still got it in him.”READ MORE ON MAN UTDAnother fan said: “What a keeper.”One hailed: “Impressive form well done De Gea.”Another gushed: “Who would have guessed he would be incredible…”De Gea also posted on social media: “Big big victory, we continue the chase to our aims.” Most read in FootballCASINO SPECIAL – BEST CASINO WELCOME OFFERSHe joined United from Atletico Madrid in 2011 and spent 12 years with the club, winning a Premier League title, Europa League, FA Cup and League Cup. De Gea also won United’s Player of The Season award FOUR times but was overlooked by Erik ten Hag, who instead signed Andre Onana. Ten Hag has since been sacked with Ruben Amorim expected to leave Sporting Lisbon to replace the Dutchman. Ruud van Nistelrooy hints he wants to stay at Man Utd in plea to Ruben Amorim as interim vows to ‘serve’ club More

  • in

    Ex-Arsenal ace Alex Iwobi releases music video for his second single What’s Luv? as fans call it ‘great retirement plan’

    ALEX IWOBI has released the music video for his second single “What’s Luv?”The Fulham star, 28, launched his music career with debut EP “Don’t Shoot” earlier this year.Alex Iwobi has released his new singleCredit: X / alexiwobiThe Fulham star has released the music video for his new trackCredit: X / alexiwobiIwobi, 28, loved using music to express himself off the pitchCredit: X / alexiwobiIwobi’s fellow footballers Chuba Akpom and Medy Elito also featured on “Don’t Shoot”.The former Arsenal midfielder’s second track is described as “a celebration of his African roots with a blend of Afro–Swing mixed with Rap”.For the song, Iwobi collaborated with pal SPKS and MBrown.The Nigeria international has described music as an ideal outlet for him off the pitch.READ MORE IN FOOTBALLHe said: “Music has always been a passion of mine, and a way for me to express myself away from football, music is a great tool and I’ve always used it as a productive way to share how I feel.”Historically no Premier League player has brought out music with their name and face attached to it, but I like to be different and make a difference.“Growing up in an area of London that is challenging for some people, I know how hard it can be and I’m grateful to have aplatform to try and make a difference.”I don’t want young people to feel they have to fit in just one box. I want them to be encouraged to achieve their dreams, to put their focus into positive things.Most read in FootballBEST FREE BET SIGN UP OFFERS FOR UK BOOKMAKERSIwobi has been in good form for Fulham this seasonCredit: Reuters”Creating music doesn’t take anything away from my football, it actually helps me switch off.”I will always work hard and try to improve in my sport, but this is a good use of my spare time.”Former Arsenal star to make history as he launches new career alongside forgotten ex-Gunners ace Fans on social media have been loving Iwobi’s second release.One wrote: “Great retirement plan. And it’s not nonsense.”While a second gushed: “Ok Iwobi this is a vibe. Permission to help u push it.”A third gushed: “This is a solid jam.”And another added: “Banger off and on the pitch!!!”Iwobi has been in good form for Fulham this season.READ MORE SUN STORIESLast time out he scored on his return to Everton as the Cottagers earned a 1-1 draw.Marco Silva’s side will return to action on Monday night when they host Brentford in a West London derby.Who are these famous footballers? More

  • in

    Box office Ruben Amorim already has mentor Mourinho’s aura and can now match his Chelsea feats by sorting Man Utd mess

    RUBEN AMORIM smiled when Man United’s soon-to-be manager was asked what he likes about the Premier League and said: “Everything”.One of Europe’s most sought-after young coaches clearly wanted to expand on SunSport’s question here in Lisbon.Ruben Amorim revealed he likes ‘everything’ about the Premier LeagueCredit: EPAThe Portuguese coach already has mentor Jose Mourinho’s auraCredit: GettyBut he found himself in an utterly ridiculous situation before he left the media room at Sporting’s training ground.Amorim has promised he will be able to talk more freely about his impending job at Old Trafford after Friday’s Primeira Liga match at home to Estrela Amadora.Yet already, it is clear that this bloke is proper box office.And it is blindingly obvious he is relishing the chance of getting to grips with English football.READ MORE ON MAN UTDHis pre-match press conferences at the club’s training base — the Academia Cristiano Ronaldo — are such a terrific watch that on social media, there is a countdown clock for each of his media briefings.Entertaining press conferences? Does this remind you of another coach from Portugal?Indeed, Jose Mourinho was 41 when he announced he was the Special One after arriving at Chelsea. Amorim will head to Old Trafford even younger, aged 39.Most read in FootballBack in 2018, Amorim completed a performance internship under Mourinho at United as he got an early taste for life in ManchesterCredit: Twitter @Mourinho_XtraFOOTBALL FREE BETS AND SIGN UP DEALSMourinho’s birthday is on January 26, while Amorim’s is on January 27, but it looks as though he will follow in his fellow countryman’s footsteps in all sorts of ways.Even though Amorim has been unable to confirm he is heading to England, his two press conferences since the United news emerged have been fascinating.Sir Dave Brailsford appears to confirm Ruben Amorim deal to Man Utd fans as he leaves Old Trafford He has a twinkle in his eye, a good sense of humour, answers most questions in great detail and is obviously a terrific communicator in perfect English.He will certainly need those skills at Old Trafford, in both the way he deals with the playing staff, the board members and how he talks to the fans.Mourinho often used his press conferences — in fact he still does — with a clear plan of what he wants to say. He releases certain messages to his own players, opponents and the supporters. Amorim is the same.Erik ten Hag handled himself impressively throughout his time at Manchester United but he was lacking in charisma.Amorim has an aura, just like Mourinho.His career has been on an upwards trajectory so it has been an easy ride so far.There have certainly been no touchline histrionics like a certain other coach.It will also be fascinating how he deals with a run of poor results.Or when he is thrown a curveball, like a star player doing something stupid like going on a booze bender in Belfast.What is crazy, though, is Sporting president Frederico Varandas has insisted that Amorim stays for the next three games.Firstly, Friday’s local derby, then Tuesday’s home Champions League game with Manchester City and the trip to Braga on November 10.Amorim has already won two Primeira Liga titles with Sporting but faces a huge test against Pep Guardiola’s Man City in the Champions League next TuesdayCredit: GettyAmorim did not watch United’s win over Leicester on Wednesday because he was studying City in their Carabao Cup defeat at Spurs.And this City match really is rotten timing for Amorim.Despite boasting a 100 per cent record in the league, Sporting have also done well in the Champions League and are currently unbeaten in eighth place.But what happens if Sporting are taken apart by City?If Amorim engineers a famous win, then this will enhance his burgeoning reputation.But if Sporting are thrashed 5-0 and Erling Haaland scores another hat-trick, which is hardly out of the question, then United’s fans will be forced to welcome a manager who has just been out-smarted by Pep Guardiola. Not a good start.Ruben Amorim leaves Sporting on a highBy Charlie WyettRUBEN AMORIM would have preferred to leave Lisbon in a blaze of glory after winning a third Primeira Liga title.Yet football does not work like that. And in what was surely his final game before taking charge of Manchester United, Amorim prepared to say his goodbyes at a half-empty Estadio Jose Alvalade in a League Cup quarter-final against Nacional.Sporting won 3-1 thanks to  second-half goals by captain  Morten Hjulmand and Viktor Gyokeres, who scored two.Luis Esteves pulled back for Madeira-based Nacional.The stadium  will be a good deal more lively on Tuesday when Manchester City are here for  a Champions League match — although Amorim should by then have his feet firmly under his desk at Old Trafford.Liverpool and Aston Villa were both interested in Europe’s most sought-after coach. Even City could have been a possible destination post-Pep Guardiola.Yet the United job is one Amorim, 39,  could not turn  down — even if not everyone saw it that way at Sporting last night.There is clearly a huge split in the Portuguese club’s fan base over their coach leaving at this stage of the season with many believing he should have seen the job through.Yet Amorim, along with the three-man coaching team who are expected to follow him, leaves a club in a much better state than when he arrived here in 2020.Inside the stadium, there was applause — albeit muted — when his name was read out before the game along with the line-ups.And there did not appear to be any jeers when Amorim shuffled out from the tunnel awkwardly towards the dugout.So, while his departure is hard to take for some, none of the fans will forget his legacy.This is a club which is back as the dominant force in Portugal. Even this term, Sporting have won their first nine league games, scoring 30 goals and conceding just two.They are also eighth in the Champions League table, which is one hell of an effort.In contrast, Lisbon was not exactly hit by League Cup fever last night.Amorim made lots of changes, which saw Sporting’s star man Gyokeres, the former Coventry striker, start on the bench.There was, however, a first appearance in six weeks for former Tottenham winger Marcus Edwards. He is certainly one player who has been transformed by Amorim since arriving at the club from Vitoria in 2022 and will be sorry to see the coach leave.While he changed his team, Amorim stuck with his tried and trusted formation of a back three.It will certainly be something Manchester United’s fans will have to get used to over the  coming months.But looking at the Premier League table, none of them will be complaining about the change.Amorim often talks about stability and he was asked about the prospect of leaving his comfort zone at yesterday’s press conference.He was also quizzed about playing a part in his backroom staff enjoying life-changing pay rises by going to Old Trafford.As for a change in scenery, he said: “I think all coaches need that.“I don’t want to go into too much detail. Staff? We have very good conditions here.“Six years ago we were at Casa Pia and we were almost paid to work. It’s not about money.“When I said staff, staff involves a lot more people. Physiotherapists, wardrobe assistants. Not just the staff you’re referring to.“It’s hard to find these environments. That was one of the reasons I always wanted to stay here.“It was the people I work with. Stability. “I think that in everyone’s life there are times when we’re doing really well, but then we want something more, maybe to prove something more.”Amorim is about to get that chance. The problem is that inherits a dysfunctional United squad, and one without an A-lister.They could do with a player of the stature of the old Red Devils star who now has Sporting’s training ground named after him.READ MORE SUN STORIESAmorim, though, will be supremely confident he can sort out this mess at Old Trafford.If he is able to do so, this achievement would be every bit as impressive as what Mourinho managed at Chelsea.Mourinho won two Prem titles, an FA Cup and two League Cups in three seasons at ChelseaRuben Amorim is ‘Mourinho 2.0’ who turned Sporting from ‘walking dead’ into Portuguese champs… he can revive Man UtdWHEN Ruben Amorim took charge of Sporting Lisbon in March 2020, one club official compared their situation to the “walking dead”, writes Jordan Davies.Optimism and hope was at an all-time low.But the Amorim-effect was almost instantaneous, guiding the Portuguese sleeping giants to their first league title for 19 years in 2020/21, losing just once and only conceding 20 goals.Since then, Sporting have lifted another league title in 2023/24 – as well as two League Cups – and currently sit top with nine wins from nine this term.He may be young, but Amorim already has an eye for rebuilding and revitalising fallen super powers with his infectious charisma and intense tactical philosophy that hardly ever wavers. The “walking dead” at Manchester United must be praying for a similar sort of revival.And they may just get it from one of the most talented young coaches on the continent – a man accustomed to breathing new life back into crumbling institutions such as Old Trafford.Amorim has spent the last decade dreaming of one day gracing England’s Premier League, such was his admiration for an ex-United boss in Jose Mourinho growing up.Often nicknamed ‘Mourinho 2.0’, Amorim spent a week with his coaching idol in an internship capacity at United’s Carrington training base in 2018, going on to cite him as his “reference point”.United should not be expecting a mini-Mourinho, as Amorim said himself: “Mourinho is one of a kind. There won’t be another Mourinho. Mourinho is unique.”And yet, you cannot help but compare the two.For all the mismanagement in the Old Trafford hot seats over the years, this would be a real get – finally a slap in the face United’s Prem rivals have no answer for. More