More stories

  • in

    Premier League stars at greater risk of dementia from heading the ball than footballers in the past

    PREMIER League stars are at greater risk of dementia from heading the ball than footballers in the past, experts fear.The danger is growing because the modern, plastic ball travels at greater speed and is headed more often.
    Previous studies suggest players from yesteryear were at up to five times higher risk. World Cup winners, including Jack Charlton, were among those affectedCredit: Rex
    It will lead to an explosion in dementia cases unless action is taken, say researchers, who have launched a ground-breaking study to find ways to lessen the effect.
    Brain expert Professor Willie Stewart said the dementia risk could be worse for players in the modern era.
    He warned: “It’s a car crash waiting to happen.”
    Previous studies suggest players from yesteryear were at up to five times higher risk.
    World Cup winners, including Jack Charlton, were among those affected.
    Now Prof Stewart is signing up 150 ex-pros from the 1990s and 2000s for his study at Glasgow University.
    .css-qu9fel{border-top:1px solid #dcdddd;}.css-b9nmbi{margin-bottom:16px;border-top:1px solid #dcdddd;}.css-1qsre5o{display:-webkit-box;display:-webkit-flex;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;height:100%;-webkit-align-items:flex-start;-webkit-box-align:flex-start;-ms-flex-align:flex-start;align-items:flex-start;-webkit-align-content:flex-start;-ms-flex-line-pack:flex-start;align-content:flex-start;-webkit-box-flex-wrap:nowrap;-webkit-flex-wrap:nowrap;-ms-flex-wrap:nowrap;flex-wrap:nowrap;-webkit-flex-direction:column;-ms-flex-direction:column;flex-direction:column;-webkit-box-pack:justify;-webkit-justify-content:space-between;justify-content:space-between;}.css-q8gelu{margin-bottom:24px;}.css-7ysxcx{padding:0;text-transform:uppercase;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}.css-7ysxcx:hover:not(:disabled){-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}.css-jkwlot{display:-webkit-box;display:-webkit-flex;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;height:100%;-webkit-align-items:center;-webkit-box-align:center;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center;-webkit-flex-direction:row;-ms-flex-direction:row;flex-direction:row;-webkit-box-pack:justify;-webkit-justify-content:space-between;justify-content:space-between;padding:0;text-transform:uppercase;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}.css-jkwlot:hover:not(:disabled){-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}.css-1x7hydu{font-family:The Sun;font-size:24px;line-height:1.1666666666666667;font-weight:400;letter-spacing:0%;font-stretch:semi-condensed;padding:1px 0px;}.css-1x7hydu::before{content:”;display:block;height:0;width:0;margin-bottom:calc(-0.24520833333333342em + -0.5px);}.css-1x7hydu::after{content:”;display:block;height:0;width:0;margin-top:-0.2333333333333334em;}.css-1lobn43{display:inline;font:inherit;margin:0;color:rgba(0,0,0,1);}.css-1lobn43 svg{fill:rgba(0,0,0,1);}Most read in Football.css-1gojmfd{margin-bottom:16px;}.css-zdjvqv{display:-webkit-box;display:-webkit-flex;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;height:100%;-webkit-align-items:flex-start;-webkit-box-align:flex-start;-ms-flex-align:flex-start;align-items:flex-start;-webkit-align-content:flex-start;-ms-flex-line-pack:flex-start;align-content:flex-start;-webkit-box-flex-wrap:nowrap;-webkit-flex-wrap:nowrap;-ms-flex-wrap:nowrap;flex-wrap:nowrap;-webkit-flex-direction:column;-ms-flex-direction:column;flex-direction:column;-webkit-box-pack:space-around;-ms-flex-pack:space-around;-webkit-justify-content:space-around;justify-content:space-around;margin-top:calc(-12px/2);margin-bottom:calc(-12px/2);}.css-zdjvqv:before,.css-zdjvqv:after{content:”;display:block;}.css-1meuhfk{display:-webkit-inline-box;display:-webkit-inline-flex;display:-ms-inline-flexbox;display:inline-flex;margin-top:calc(12px/2);margin-bottom:calc(12px/2);}
    He told the Dementias 2022 conference in London: “The old balls were heavier when they got wet but they were also travelling slower.
    “Modern balls don’t absorb water and move fast through the air — the speed of the ball is a bigger problem.”
    We pay for your stories!Do you have a story for The Sun news desk? More

  • in

    N.F.L. to Drop Race-Based Measures in Concussion Settlement

    Black players’ dementia claims were being measured differently from white players’. The change could prompt a reassessment of hundreds of previously denied cases.The N.F.L. said it would scrap the use of a disputed race-based method of evaluating dementia claims made by former players in the league’s concussion settlement and pledged to evaluate for evidence of bias the hundreds of claims that had already been filed.The announcement came several months after the federal judge overseeing the roughly $1 billion settlement ordered the league and lawyers representing the 20,000 former players who are covered by the agreement to review the use of separate standards for evaluating dementia in white and Black players.In August, two retired Black players, Kevin Henry and Najeh Davenport, filed a civil rights suit and a suit against the seven-year-old settlement that accused the league of “explicitly and deliberately” discriminating against Black players by using separate race-based benchmarks to determine their eligibility for dementia-based payouts, which can be worth hundreds of thousands of dollars.The judge dismissed their suits, but the cases brought light to the evaluations and prompted members of Congress to request data from the N.F.L. to determine whether Black players were being discriminated against. They also prompted an ABC News report and led more than a dozen wives of Black retired N.F.L. players to send the judge in the case a petition with nearly 50,000 signatures calling for an end to race-norming.As it has in previous responses, the N.F.L. denied that the use of the race-based norms was discriminatory. But in a statement Wednesday, the league said it was committed to eliminating the use of those norms and finding race-neutral alternatives with the help of specialists in neuropsychology. While those new measures have not been identified, the decision to review old dementia claims under new assessment tools could mean that potentially hundreds more players will receive payments from the settlement.“Everyone agrees race-based norms should be replaced, but no off-the-shelf alternative exists, and that’s why these experts are working to solve this decades-old issue,” the league said. “The replacement norms will be applied prospectively and retrospectively for those players who otherwise would have qualified for an award but for the application of race-based norms.”While some former players have blamed the N.F.L., some have also taken aim at Christopher Seeger, the lead lawyer for more than 20,000 former players, who the players say knew about the abuse of race-based benchmarks as early as 2018 and did not address the issue. Lawyers for Henry and Davenport, the two former players who accused the league of discrimination, asked the court to replace Seeger in March.The former N.F.L. players Ken Jenkins, right, and Clarence Vaughn III, center right, and their wives, Amy Lewis, center, and Brooke Vaughn, left, carried petitions demanding an end to the use of race-based benchmarks in the N.F.L. concussion settlement to the federal courthouse in Philadelphia in May.Matt Rourke/Associated PressIn a statement also released on Wednesday, Seeger apologized for not having recognized the problems caused by the use of separate benchmarks for Black and white players.“I am sorry for the pain this episode has caused Black former players and their families,” Seeger said. “Ultimately, this settlement only works if former players believe in it, and my goal is to regain their trust and ensure the N.F.L. is fully held to account.”That trust may take time to rebuild. Lacey Leonard, whose husband, Louis, 36, played for six teams over five seasons, said Seeger’s apology was not enough. Leonard received a settlement after filing a dementia claim because he has a host of cognitive issues, including memory loss, anger and depression. When the claims auditor found no problems with Leonard’s claim, the N.F.L. appealed the settlement, and his claim was reversed.“Honestly, it was a half apology,” Lacey Leonard said in a phone interview. “I think the N.F.L. owes more to disabled players. It’s disheartening that in 2021 that we are still fighting systemic racism.”The N.F.L. did not say how long it would take for the league, Seeger and the panel of experts to create a new system to evaluate dementia claims. More than $800 million in claims has already been approved by the settlement administrator for a range of neurological and cognitive diseases. That number could increase significantly if many dementia claims that were initially rejected are reversed and approved.It is unclear how many Black players may have been misdiagnosed or had diagnoses that were overturned. More than 7,000 former players took free neuropsychological and neurological exams offered in the settlement. Some of them were told they did not have dementia and might be unaware of how their exams were scored.Cyril Smith, a lawyer for Henry and Davenport, asserted that white players’ dementia claims were being approved at two to three times the rate of those of Black players. But Smith was unable to substantiate his claim because, he said, Seeger and the N.F.L. had not shared any data on the approval rates for dementia claims by white and Black players.Seeger said that data would be released when new tests for dementia claims and an investigation looking at whether players were discriminated against had been submitted to the court. More

  • in

    Chris Kamara has swollen tongue and slurred speech due to underactive thyroid after undergoing scan for ‘brain fog’

    SKY SPORTS legend and former footballer Chris Kamara has revealed his relief after a brain scan showed NO signs of dementia.The 63-year-old decided to book in to see a radiologist after being left shocked at how ‘slow’ he was on a recent appearance on BBC’s The One Show.
    Chris Kamara thankfully revealed his brain scan had showed no signs of dementiaCredit: Channel 4
    Kammy shared photos of him in the radiology departmentCredit: Channel 4
    The former Portsmouth, Stoke and Leeds star has previously described having ‘brain fog’ and being worried it might be related to heading the ball during his long footballing career.
    Last month, he went for a scan as a precaution.
    On Tuesday’s edition of Steph’s Packed Lunch on Channel 4, Kammy revealed the scan showed no signs of dementia, saying: “They didn’t find anything.
    “Watching that back [a clip from an earlier episode of Packed Lunch], it’s slow and I know that’s not me of old.
    “I went to Pontefract to the radiology department. The results were no loss of brain mass and very few lesions, which means no clinical relevance. So yes!”
    Kamara told host Steph McGovern he had further tests to investigate why he has been experiencing ‘brain fog’.
    He added: “There are loads of things I can track and I’m thinking ‘what’s going on?’.
    “After the blood test I had, I’ve got an underactive thyroid. I’m suffering with a swollen tongue which causes you to slur your words, slows down.
    Kammy had a distinguished football career – but has become more famous for his Sky Sports workCredit: Getty

    “Not your thoughts because the thoughts are there, but transferring those thoughts to the mouth to get you to talk coherently. All that sort of stuff.
    “Feeling cold, even warm days you’re shivering and cold, weakness, muscle fatigue, tiredness.”
    Steph asked Kammy to recall an experience he had during an appearance on The One Show which caused him to worry.
    Kamara revealed his shock at how ‘slow’ he was on live TV prompted him to get checked outCredit: Channel 4
    Kammy replied: “I was on with Alex Jones and Michael Ball, I did the menu for the show live and not a problem
    “Michael Ball talked to me about the Christmas album and said ‘name some of the songs’ and my mind had gone completely blank and I couldn’t think of anything.
    “That was the first time my wife said to me, ‘there’s something not quite right, you need to get it checked out’.”
    “The blood test which showed the underactive thyroid has explained everything along the way.”
    Kamara’s concerns came after Gary Lineker called for football to ban heading in training because players are three and a half times more likely to suffer from a brain disorder.
    WHAT IS AN UNDERACTIVE THYROID?An underactive thyroid gland (hypothyroidism) is where your thyroid gland does not produce enough hormones.
    Common signs of an underactive thyroid are tiredness, weight gain and feeling depressed.
    An underactive thyroid can often be successfully treated by taking daily hormone tablets to replace the hormones your thyroid is not making.
    There’s no way of preventing an underactive thyroid. Most cases are caused either by the immune system attacking the thyroid gland and damaging it, or by damage to the thyroid that occurs during some treatments for an overactive thyroid or thyroid cancer.
    Symptoms include:
    symptoms including:

    tiredness
    weight gain
    depression
    being sensitive to the cold
    dry skin and hair
    muscle aches

    From the NHS website.

    Chris Kamara reveals he is going to hospital for a precautionary brain scan after years of heading footballs More

  • in

    Black N.F.L. Players Want New Advocate in Concussion Settlement

    Players said the lawyer for the N.F.L. retiree class knew that race-based criteria were used to deny Black players’ dementia claims. A review of eight such rejections seems to support their argument.Two retired N.F.L. players who have filed dementia-related claims in the N.F.L. concussion settlement, and have accused the league of discriminating against Black players, want their own representative to attend a mediation aimed at addressing the use of race-based benchmarks to determine eligibility for payouts.Kevin Henry and Najeh Davenport argued in a lawsuit that the separate scoring curves — one for Black athletes, another for white players — used by neuropsychologists to evaluate dementia-related claims “explicitly and deliberately” discriminated against hundreds if not thousands of Black players. But last week, Judge Anita B. Brody of the Eastern District of Pennsylvania dismissed their lawsuit and ordered a mediator to address her concerns about the practice.The players are seeking a new representative because they said Christopher Seeger, the lawyer for more than 20,000 former players in the class action settlement, knew about the abuse of race-based benchmarks as early as 2018 and did not address the issue.“It is not realistic to expect that concerns about race-norming will be addressed effectively by parties who do not view the current use of race-norming as a problem,” Henry and Davenport’s lawyer wrote in their request.The players say that Black former players may have had their claims denied because the benchmarks used to assess rates of cognitive decline deliberately make it harder for them to receive payouts worth hundreds of thousands of dollars, an accusation Seeger denied in a phone interview on Tuesday with The New York Times.Seeger said he was aware of a handful of objections to race-norming in the past few years. He said he intervened in at least one case and that the player received a $1.5 million payout as a result. However, “there has not been a systemic attempt to mistreat Black players in the settlement,” he said.To remove any ambiguity, though, Seeger said he would fight to have race-norming entirely stripped from the settlement.“I need the players to believe in me, I need them to believe in the settlement and I need them to believe they are treated fairly,” he said.Suspicions remain. As the representative for all 20,000 players in the settlement, Seeger signed off on the use of race-based benchmarks in 2014, when the settlement was being approved. The N.F.L. and Seeger note that the use of race norms is not mandatory, though Seeger acknowledged that some doctors charged with evaluating players may be under the misguided perception that it is.Kevin Henry, a longtime defensive end for the Pittsburgh Steelers, is one of two Black players who have petitioned for a new representative for retired players in the N.F.L.’s landmark concussions settlement.Matthew Odom for The New York TimesThe New York Times reviewed the confidential records of eight Black former players whose claims of dementia were denied. In the cases, which date to 2018, diagnoses made without regard to race showed significant enough decline in function for the players to be eligible for payouts.But a second doctor tossed out those diagnoses because the initial doctors had not used the race norms developed by Dr. Robert Heaton that have been standard in settlement claims.“The NFL guidelines are very specific in requiring the use of the Heaton norms for several tests,” an appeals doctor wrote in denying a dementia diagnosis for a player whose career spanned the 1990s and 2000s. To illustrate the point, the doctor listed the player’s test scores after race-based benchmarks were applied to show there was no “evidence of significant cognitive decline.”Lawyers who represent dozens of Black former players said that Black players with similar test scores as white players have been disqualified after racial benchmarks were used, a violation of their civil rights.“Unlike many civil rights cases, the use of Heaton’s race-based norms is discriminatory on its face,” Justin Wyatt, a lawyer for more than 100 players, wrote in a confidential filing in 2019 after one of his clients had his dementia diagnosis overturned. “By definition, Heaton’s race based norms have the effect of treating blacks differently than whites.”It is unclear how many Black players may have been misdiagnosed or had their diagnoses overturned. Cyril Smith, a lawyer for Henry and Davenport, claimed that white players are getting their dementia claims approved at two to three times the rate of Black players.But Smith was unable to substantiate his claim because, he said, Seeger and the N.F.L. have not shared any data on the approval rates of dementia claims by white and Black players.Seeger said this week that he will release that data once his investigation into the use of racial benchmarks in the settlement is completed in the coming weeks and that any claim that was “improperly affected by race-norming” will be reviewed.Smith and Wyatt said the only way to ensure that Black players’ claims have not been mishandled is to have every one of their neuropsychological exams rescored without the use of racial benchmarks. More than 7,000 former players took free neuropsychological and neurological exams offered in the settlement. Some of them were told they did not have dementia and may be unaware of how their exams were scored.It is unclear whether the N.F.L. will approve having every player’s exams rescored because the payouts that could result would be worth potentially hundreds of thousands of dollars each. More than $800 million in claims have already been approved for a range of neurological and cognitive diseases, and Seeger expects that amount to top $1 billion.The N.F.L. said in a statement that there is “no merit to the claim of discrimination,” citing the use of demographic adjustments as common practice in such examinations. It contended that the number of players potentially affected by the use of race-based benchmarks is a fraction of what has been alleged because, among other reasons, “many claims were denied for reasons that have nothing to do with the norms and any rescoring would have no impact on those denials.”The league added: “The N.F.L. nevertheless is committed to helping find alternative testing techniques that will lead to diagnostic accuracy without relying on race-based norms.”To assess cases of dementia, doctors must estimate what a person’s cognitive skills were years ago and compare them to the patient’s current condition. In theory, race-norms are designed to help doctors approximate the cognitive skills of Black and white people in the past.But using race to estimate one’s cognition is fraught because it does not account for factors like a person’s health, education or economic background. Many people — such as those who come from biracial families — do not fit neatly into a single racial category. N.F.L. players are also a unique group because almost all have attended at least three years of university. Comparing players to larger pools of white and Black Americans could be misleading, experts said.“Among the scientific community, it is now widely recognized that race/ethnicity represents a crude proxy for lifelong social experiences, and biologically based racial differences in I.Q. have been debunked,” Dr. Katherine Possin, of the Memory and Aging Center at the University of California San Francisco, wrote in the journal JAMA Neurology in December. “Even with the best norms, the diagnosis of cognitive disorders should not be decided based on a plug-and-play formula of cognitive test scores.”The debate over the use of race norms is not unique to the N.F.L. settlement. In the past, their use has led, intentionally or not, Black patients being denied treatment for many medical conditions, Darshali Vyas, Leo Eisenstein and David Jones wrote in the New England Journal of Medicine in August.The doctors said that problems with race-norming also exist in the criminal justice system, where it is used to help determine police intervention in communities and prison sentences. Some members of Congress want to eliminate algorithms that discriminate against women and people of color by deciding everything from the type of advertisements people see online to how their applications for jobs, credit cards and other products are treated.“Prior forms of racial discrimination based on human biases are now being embedded into algorithms that appear to be race-neutral but aren’t because they are based on data and racial profiling that went on in the past,” said Dorothy Roberts, a professor of Africana Studies, law and sociology at the University of Pennsylvania who studies the use algorithms. “Technology can be used to promote equality or perpetuate inequality. It depends on who’s in control of it and what data they are putting into the algorithms.” More

  • in

    Gary Lineker to get checked for dementia as he calls for heading ban in training

    GARY Lineker has said he will get extra checks for dementia and wants heading banned from training at all levels.The Match of the Day host, 60, revealed co-stars Alan Shearer and Ian Wright fear the effects after years of playing.
    Gary Lineker called for heading to be banned from training at all levelsCredit: Getty
    Research shows ex-pros are 3.5 times likelier to die from a brain disorder than the general public.
    Lineker scored more headed goals for England than any other player.
    He said: “I’ll have my triannual test this summer and ask if there’s anything they can establish around the brain.
    The Match of the Day host revealed he and co-stars Alan Shearer and Ian Wright fear the effects of dementiaCredit: BBC
    Lineker scored more headed goals for England than any other playerCredit: Getty

    “Because I don’t see how, given the circumstances, any footballer wouldn’t be worried about it.”
    He added: “If I’d known what I know now, I would have certainly limited the amount of heading I did.
    “It’s hard to imagine the game without heading, but maybe it’s worth trialling.”
    Gary Lineker suffers from such bad arthritis that he’s been forced to quit golf as he can’t hold a club
    GOT a story? RING The Sun on 0207 782 4104 or WHATSAPP on 07423720250 or EMAIL exclusive@the-sun.co.uk More

  • in

    Risks of dementia could be greater for female footballers, says expert running ground-breaking study

    WOMEN footballers are being urged to take part in a study to determine if they are at a higher risk of getting dementia than male players. 
    And its lead scientist believes female athletes heading the ball could be in greater danger of developing the condition diagnosed in five of 1966 World Cup winners. 

    University of East Anglia scientists are studying the effect heading a football has on female playersCredit: Getty Images – Getty

    Retired Crystal Palace ace Mark Bright and ex-Norwich City players are among the former professionals involved in the SCORES Project run by the University of East Anglia (UEA). 
    Dr Michael Grey, the study’s chief researcher, revealed his team are desperate to see more women players over the age of 40 to volunteer to take part. 
    Their call-out comes less than a month after the death of Manchester United and England hero Nobby Stiles who lived with dementia in his later years. 

    Professional female players who are 40 are being encouraged to take part in research Credit: Getty Images – Getty
    And it follows University of Glasgow research, funded by the FA, which revealed that retired male players are five times more likely to suffer from Alzheimer’s compared to the average person. 

    Dr Grey told SunSport three amateur women footballers are currently involved in the study, with netballers, swimmers, tennis and badminton players making up the rest of the 37 sportswomen taking part. 
    And Sky Sports News reports the project is yet to include a single former professional female player. 
    Dr Grey said: “We know very little about how this affects female players, but we think female players are at even greater risk of developing sport-related dementia than male players.
    “We have already signed up more than 35 professional male players but we have very few women footballers in the study so far. 

    “We know that there is greater risk of dementia in former professional footballers, and we think this is related to repetitive heading of the ball.
    “We know there are physical and physiological differences between male and female players and this could be important when it comes to the impact of repeatedly heading the ball.
    “But we don’t fully understand the impact these differences could have, so we are encouraging former amateur and professional female players to come forward to help us with our project.
    “We are looking for women and men over 40, who live in the UK and do not have a diagnosis of dementia. 
    “We are tracking their brain health over time. And we hope to follow these footballers for many years to come.”

    Sir Geoff Hurst is among leading football figures calling for a ban on children heading footballsCredit: Getty Images – Getty
    The issue of dementia in football has become a pressing concern for the sport with some of the game’s biggest names supporting a ban on children heading the ball. 
    1966 World Cup legend Sir Geoff Hurst is among the leading figures backing the call following his England peers’ struggles with dementia. 
    And the Professional Footballers’ Association announced its plans to create a new taskforce to analyse the issue of brain injury diseases in football. More

  • in

    Brave dementia sufferer and Harrogate legend Jim Hague is lost without football while wife fears for his mental health

    JIM HAGUE loves Harrogate Town and this lockdown is affecting his mental health far worse than most fans.
    For the 78-year-old suffers from dementia and being segregated from the club due to the government restrictions has had a detrimental effect on his life.

    Dementia sufferer Jim Hague is a legend on and off the pitch at Harrogate

    Jim is a club legend both on and off the pitch.
    The former striker – who started as a defender – remains their youngest first-team debutant at 14 and made a record 402 appearances, topping the Yorkshire club’s all-time scoring charts with 135 goals.
    He also served on the club’s committee and, six years ago, won an FA award as groundsman of the year.
    Yet – despite his condition – he is still involved with the Sulpherites and, right up to this second lockdown, was working at their Wetherby Road stadium with a team of maintenance volunteers every Monday and Friday.And that interaction with fellow Harrogate lovers gave him something to look forward to twice a week – especially with fans not allowed into the ground to watch games.

    Club record appearance holder and scorer Jim Hague helps tidy up ground
    Jenny – Jim’s wife for 54 years – told me: “He was sweeping leaves and cleaning the terraces out.“He had only just gone back after the first lockdown and they were doing so much work but now they’re not allowed in.“It’s been bad enough that he hasn’t been able to watch them play since March – although our son Jason has been able to stream the games for Jim.“But it’s been a hard time. Being able to watch games and go to the ground to meet old friends and lovers of Harrogate gave him a reason to get out of bed.“Harrogate has been his life and, for people with dementia, taking away something from them that they love and are used to is not good. It has a seriously negative impact. It’s the worst thing that could’ve happened to his life.“People with dementia need stability and anything out of the ordinary throws them into a downward spiral.“For Jim, his life revolved around watching Harrogate Town and being able to go down there to help.”

    People with dementia need stability and anything out of the ordinary throws them into a downward spiral.’
    Jenny Hague, Jim’s wife

    Jim left Harrogate when he was 16 to join Bolton Wanderers as a youth player. And he was such a promising talent, the legendary Nat Lofthouse spent a lot of time with him on the training pitch.Jenny, 76, said: “Nat would teach him how to head the ball – which is probably why he has dementia.”

    Bolton and England legend Nat Lofthouse taught Jim how to head the ball
    After around 18 months with Bolton, he joined Leeds but failed to make the grade there and returned to his beloved Harrogate to play in the Yorkshire League.Jim has a great story about his favourite Town manager – former pre-war Chelsea and England star John Townrow – that would send a modern-day HR department into meltdown.
    He said: “If we did something wrong in a game he used to punch us! It certainly taught us a lesson.”

    Jim loved playing for Harrogate “because the team was close-knit and had a real camaraderie.”

    Jim, far left, with Harrogate team after winning the West Riding Cup in 1973

    Jim, front row, far left, poses for Harrogate team photo in the 1967-68 season

    Harrogate Town celebrate winning promotion to League TwoCredit: Getty Images – Getty
    Jim had to call time on his playing career with Harrogate in 1973 at the age of 32 after he passed out while with his wife on a visit to the Yorkshire coastal village of Sandsend, near Whitby.Jenny explained: “He had a heart problem and that finished his playing days there.”But, incredibly, he made a comeback and went on to play into his early 40s for Collingham – a local village team.However, he was serving on Harrogate’s committee and later became the groundsman.And there is a great tale from December 2012 ahead of a crunch FA Cup second-round match with Hastings United.The club were struggling with a newly-laid pitch because Harrogate got 340 per cent more rain that winter compared to the previous year – and had five home games called off in a row.Ten minutes before what was then Town’s biggest match in their history, the referee threatened to postpone the match unless there was more sand treatment to the pitch.

    Jim had been given the day off to enjoy the occasion with his grandson Alfie but, as soon as he heard, he rushed out of the stand and, along with the under-17 squad that he had taught how to replace turf and repair diverts, got to work.And they got the pitch playable with one minute spare.Jim’s grand-daughter Olivia, 17, has also proudly represented the club in the girls’ section.

    Jim and Jenny Hague have been married to each other for 54 years
    Despite having dementia, Jim still was able to talk to me about his love of the club that is playing in the EFL for the first time in their history.He said: “I’m delighted and proud we’re in the Football League and playing well too.“Going way back to when I was playing in the old Yorkshire League, I wanted the club to go further and they certainly have done that.“When fans are allowed back, we will have a big crowd for the first game there for sure.“The club will always have a special place in my heart.”And Harrogate will always have a special place in their hearts for Jim Hague too.

    Elliott has a cheek claiming he owns Charlton

    WHAT a cheek of Paul Elliott to demand Thomas Sandgaard leaves Charlton Athletic – claiming he does not own the club.It’s almost as mad as Donald Trump claiming he won the US election.Elliott – along with lawyer sidekick Chris Farnell – are hated by the vast majority of the Addicks’ fan-base.I ran a poll on my Twitter page the other day and asked supporters what they would do if these two gentlemen somehow regained control – and 75 per cent said they would “boycott all matches”.Both of them enjoyed driving around in flashy £90,000 Range Rovers at Charlton’s expense while the club was on its knees.In fact, when Sandgaard took over they were days from going into administration.East Street Investments – the previous owners – took almost £1million out of the club on a fleet of cars for their executives. Meanwhile former chairman Matt Southall enjoyed a luxury £12,000-a-month Thames-riverside apartment, paid for by the club.It is clear to any reasonable person that the aim of Elliott and Farnell serving “sealed court orders” to Sandgaard’s legal team is to try to scare him into paying more money to them.Sandgaard, who says he is paying £1m a month at the moment to fund the club without fans, in the coming weeks wants to lobby the EFL in a bid to rid the game of dodgy owners.And, if they are not able to achieve that, then he will start a parliamentary petition with the aim of the government bringing in legislation.We should not allow another club to suffer the same fate as Bury.If football cannot self-regulate itself effectively, then the government most certainly can do it for them. More

  • in

    Jack Charlton’s widow refuses to blame football for his dementia diagnosis amid heading ban

    ENGLAND’s victory in the 1966 World Cup is a moment so ingrained in the nation’s consciousness that it seems destined never to be forgotten.
    But for many of the heroes of that glorious day at Wembley Stadium it has now faded into a hazy mist, hard to recollect.

    Jack Charlton, pictured in 1970, died aged 85 earlier this yearCredit: Rex Features

    The towering defender was famous for his ability in the airCredit: Rex Features

    He was one of many players to be diagnosed with dementia, although his wife Pat believes the beautiful game isn’t to blame

    Nearly half of manager Sir Alf Ramsey’s illustrious 11 have succumbed to dementia, with Sir Bobby Charlton the latest to be diagnosed.
    This has reignited the long-running debate within the game about the link between heading the ball and brain disease, with England World Cup hat-trick hero Sir Geoff Hurst calling for a ban on children using their heads to strike a football.
    He has even offered to donate his own brain for dementia research after a year that has been “unbelievably brutal” for his 1966 team-mates.
    In the last 12 months 78-year-old Geoff has not only seen Sir Bobby diagnosed with dementia but also the deaths of team-mates Nobby Stiles and Bobby’s brother Jack, who both had the disease.

    The cruel reality of what this meant for the men involved is revealed in an intimate new documentary about Jack, who died in July.
    When he was recently shown his gold World Cup winner’s medal from 1966, he showed only ­surprise, saying: “Good grief, it’s me.”
    Towering defender Jack, 6ft 1½in, was famous for his ability in the air, often scoring goals with his head. But his family refuse to blame the beautiful game for his demise.
    His widow Pat says: “It’s like ­boxers getting hit in the head, nobody can actually prove it.

    “He’s enjoyed his football, would you take that away from him? I don’t think so.”
    BAD MEMORY
    In the film, Finding Jack Charlton, the star’s son John predicted it would not be the dementia which killed the England legend — and he was right. It was cancer which ended Jack’s life at the age of 85.
    The family were keen to show that while brain disease had diminished the once gregarious man, he was still living an active life to the end.

    Sir Geoff Hurst has called for a ban on children using their heads to strike a footballCredit: Getty

    Nearly half of the World Cup winning squad have succumbed to dementia

    Nobby Stiles (right), who also had the disease, died aged 78 in OctoberCredit: PA:Empics Sport

    Sir Bobby Charlton is the latest in the team to be diagnosedCredit: PA:Press Association
    In the documentary he is seen meeting fans at an event for his ­fishing charity, having fun with his grandchildren and going for a drink.
    The film, which will be released on DVD and streaming sites on ­Monday, was made by ITV football reporter Gabriel Clarke, who spent several days with Jack at his home on the outskirts of Newcastle in the year prior to his death.
    During that time medical experts recommended using music and archive footage as “trigger points” to help Jack to remember the past.
    If someone said the name Geoff Hurst he would go blank, but if he saw a picture of Sir Geoff he would recall his team-mate.

    He enjoyed his football, would you take that away from him? I don’t think so.
    Pat Charlton

    Pat did not tell Jack, her husband of six decades, that he had the ­condition because she didn’t want him to worry about it getting worse.
    She says: “I just wanted him to think he had a bad memory.”
    Gabriel believes brain damage may have been worse in the past, as the balls were heavier and players often played on, despite being concussed.
    And he tells The Sun: “My personal feeling is that there has to be more research, because five of the ten ­outfield players of the ’66 team have or had dementia.”
    As well as the Charlton brothers, holding midfielder Stiles, goal-scoring hero Martin Peters and left-back Ray Wilson also suffered from the disease.
    Yet in the population at large, only one in 14 people aged over 65 develops the condition.
    The other tragedy that Gabriel’s film highlights is the fall-out between the Charlton brothers.

    The link between heading a ball and brain disease is explored in new documentary Finding Jack Charlton

    Pat reveals she didn’t tell Jack that he had the ­condition because she didn’t want him to worry

    The pair had been married for six decadesCredit: PA:Press Association
    They might have been on the same side at Wembley against West Germany, but off the field the sibling rivalry was toxic.
    Jack admitted to resenting looking after his little brother, who was two years younger than him.
    And in one old interview Bobby told how his fiery sibling had punched him hard for questioning his decision-making.
    DIVIDED BROTHERS
    Bobby, 83, recalled: “I said, ‘You were stupid, giving that goal away’, and he punched me in the mouth straight off the couch.”
    The shy, softly spoken Bobby could not have been more different from the charismatic Jack, whose bellowing voice rang out along the corridors.
    In one interview Jack said of his brother: “I could have done more things without him than I could have done with him. I liked the sea, the countryside. Bobby didn’t.”
    Publicly those differences were glossed over. Jack chose Bobby as his best man at his wedding and presented him with the BBC Lifetime Achievement Award at the Sports Personality Of The Year ­ceremony in 2008.
    But in recent years the brothers stopped meeting altogether.

    I just wanted him to think he had a bad memory.
    Pat Charlton

    Jack’s son John reveals: “I haven’t seen uncle Bobby for a long, long time. It’s a shame.”
    Gabriel, 56, had asked if Bobby would be in the film but was told he couldn’t, due to his dementia.
    The documentary focuses on the brothers’ post-player managerial careers, in which Jack proved ­superior to Bobby, whose time as a soccer boss was over in three years.

    The documentary also looks at Jack’s relationship with brother BobbyCredit: Getty

    In recent years the brothers, pictured with Nobby Stiles, stopped meeting altogetherCredit: Getty

    While Jack was charismatic and loud, Bobby was softly spokenCredit: Getty
    Jack’s coaching prowess took him to Middlesbrough, Sheffield Wednesday, Newcastle United and finally the Republic of Ireland.
    While some pundits initially ­questioned the decision to put an Englishman in charge of the Irish national team in 1986, they soon changed their minds when he started winning games.
    Not only did Big Jack take the Republic to their first European Championship and two World Cup finals, his side also beat England 1-0 at Euro ’88.
    He was venerated in Ireland, becoming only the eighth person to be awarded honorary citizenship.
    Previously unseen footage shows Jack singing Irish songs, meeting the Pope at Italia ’90 and visiting Northern Ireland to try to smooth relations during the Troubles.
    These memories, though on film, are lost to him.
    While Jack looked through letters from Irish fans in the film, Pat said: “They think a lot of you in Ireland, don’t they?” and he replied: “I’ve no idea.”
    MISCHIEVOUS TWINKLE
    The first signs of dementia stretched back to the World Cup in the United States in 1994.
    Jack struggled to remember some of the players’ names and went for a brain scan, although the disease was not detected at that time.
    After Jack resigned as Ireland manager in 1996, when his side failed to qualify for the Euros, he suffered more health problems.
    In 2009 he fell during a holiday in Spain and three years later had a hip replacement following a collapse at home.
    The documentary shows him struggling to walk ­during a day out with the Jack Charlton Disabled Anglers Association in the summer of 2019.
    Despite being unsteady on his feet, he says in a jolly voice: “I’m falling down.”

    Players’ risk rates soar

    By Dr Willie Stewart

    By Dr WILLIE STEWART
    WE have shown that professional footballers are at high risk of death from neurodegenerative diseases – a five times higher rate with Alzheimer’s, four times higher with motor neurone ­disease and double with Parkinson’s.
    Other research we have conducted on the brains of former footballers with dementia often reveals a pathology that we recognise from boxers, rugby players and American Footballers whose only common denominator is exposure to brain injury and brain impacts.
     Dr Stewart, of Glasgow University, is a researcher into the dementia/football link.

    The film comes after a new study in the journal Science And ­Medicine In Football revealed heading a football just 20 times could affect the brain’s working memory by as much as 20 per cent.
    As for Jack, dementia did not rob him of that mischievous twinkle that fans came to love. It is just that as he said: “I could not remember a lot of the memories.”
    But now those moments will be stored forever on film.
    Finding Jack Charlton is available on DVD and download from November 23.

    Finding Jack Charlton is available from November 23Credit: Getty

    Trailer for Finding Jack Charlton
    GOT a story? RING The Sun on 0207 782 4104 or WHATSAPP on 07423720250 or EMAIL exclusive@the-sun.co.uk More